Nana Effie's Chicken Pot Pie

Candi Hummer


My grandMa Effie's pot pie recipe!
One of my favorites from when I was a child helping her make it from a very young age!
I loved being in the Kitchen with her! This recipe is simple, yet delicious and filling!


★★★★★ 1 vote

1 Hr
35 Min


  • 1 medium
    whole chicken (any chicken pieces bones in)
  • ·
  • 4 medium
    red potatoes cut into 1/2-1" pieces
  • 3
    carrots cut into 1/2-1" pieces
  • 1 small
    onion diced
  • 1 stick
    celery diced
  • 5 small
    garlic cloves diced
  • 1/4 tsp
    rosemary crushed
  • ·
    salt & pepper to taste
  • ·
  • ·

How to Make Nana Effie's Chicken Pot Pie


  1. Boil chicken in water until it is falling off the bone. (2 bone in legs and 2 bone in thighs will be enough for this recipe)
    drain chicken and SAVE water (I strain the water through a cheese cloth or very fine collinder)
  2. Once cooled, debone chicken and dice meat.
    While chicken is boiling, boil potatoes and carrots until tender but still firm.
  3. Saute onion, garlic and celery with butter and rosemary.
    Once potatoes, carrots and chicken are done, add all ingredients to pan and continue to simmer together in butter on low heat stirring occasionally.
  4. On low heat, add pepper, salt and flour to your chicken water, stirring with a whisk until thickened, about gravy consistency.
    Add all ingredients to chicken gravy.
  5. line a deep dish pie pan with pie shell, fill with filling, cover with 2nd pie shell and seal sides.
    I cut 4 small holes in the top pie shell and put a small pan under it in the oven just in case there is any mess, I have yet to have a mess from it though!
    Bake at 425* for 20-30 minutes or until top pie shell is golden brown.
  6. *Note* I used store bought pie shell for this recipe, Nana Effie never taught me how to make home made ones and I haven't gotten around to learning that yet!! I have also put this recipe in a regular baking dish and covered with biscuits for larger church recipes! Also, I have the advantage of butchering my chickens fresh, this is why I say, "Whole chicken", you can use store bought chicken as long as the bone is in it to make the best stock for this "gravy". The ingredients in this recipe (except the pie crusts) make enough filling for 2 deep dish chicken pot pies!

Printable Recipe Card

About Nana Effie's Chicken Pot Pie

Course/Dish: Chicken, Savory Pies
Main Ingredient: Chicken
Regional Style: American
Dietary Needs: Low Fat, Dairy Free, Soy Free

Show 18 Comments & Reviews

11 Tasty Chicken Casserole Recipes

11 Tasty Chicken Casserole Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Who doesn’t love an easy weeknight meal? We know we do! These easy, yummy and delicious chicken casseroles that will be your new go-to recipe for family dinners.

How To Make A Delicious Rosemary Roasted Chicken With Potatoes Recipe

How to Make a Delicious Rosemary Roasted Chicken With Potatoes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Impress your family and friends with this delicious rosemary roasted chicken with potatoes. It's anything but a basic roasted chicken. The chicken is stuffed with apples, bacon, sweet onion, and...

Chicken Breast Recipes You Need In Your Menu Rotation

Chicken Breast Recipes You Need in Your Menu Rotation

Kitchen Crew

Low in fat and high in protein, chicken breasts are a healthy and easy dinner option. If not cooked properly, though, they can be dry and not something the family...