What the Fluff(ernutter)?



Growing up, you knew it was going to be a good day if you opened up your lunchbox and found the holy grail of sandwiches inside - the Fluffernutter. You may think, "Isn't peanut butter and jelly the best lunchbox sandwich ever?" and it is for some people. But if lived in the Northeast, it was all about the Fluffernutter.

October 8th is National Fluffernutter Day, so let's celebrate this favorite childhood sandwich.

If you're not familiar with a Fluffernutter, it starts with two pieces of white bread. Can you use wheat or another type bread? Yes, but it's not the same. Classic white is the way to go.

Sandwiched inbetween the bread is peanut butter and the delicious Marshmallow Fluff. No substitutions here, Marshmallow Fluff, produced by Durkee-Mower, is definitely the preferred brand for Fluffernutter connoisseurs. Made with corn syrup, sugar, dried egg whites and vanilla, the ingredients become a spreadable marshmallow. Make sure to have a few napkins handy... things may get a bit sticky.

The History of the Fluffernutter

  • 1913: Emma and Amory Curtis (brother/sister and great, great, great grandchildren of Paul Revere) made and sold Snowflake Marshmallow Cream.

  • 1917: Archibald Query, of Somerville, Massachusetts, invented a sweet marshmallow-like spread he called "Marshmallow Cream."

  • 1918: Emma Curtis created a recipe for a peanut butter and marshmallow cream sandwich called the "Liberty Sandwich." The recipe was distributed via pamphlets and on the packaging label.

  • 1920: Due to sugar shortages because of World War I, Archibald Query sold his recipe to H. Allen Durkee and Fred L. Mower who renamed the product Toot Sweet Marshmallow Fluff, and later Marshmallow Fluff.

  • 1960: Durkee-Mower hired an advertising agency to market the Liberty Sandwich and drive sales. This is when the sandwich was officially named the Fluffernutter.
  • Source: Wikipedia

    Craving a Fluffernutter? Check out these fun recipes that put a twist on the favorite childhood treat.
    Fluffernutter Butter Bars

    Chocolate Fluffernutter Football Dip

    Chocolate Fluffernutter Bites




    3 Comments
    colleenlucky7
    Colleen Sowa - Nov 2, 2016
    Awesome! This is a favorite at our place.... Great post Janet and Kitchen Crew! ox
    Allisonthebaker
    Allison MacKay - Oct 8, 2016
    Dopey spellchecker!
    Allisonthebaker
    Allison MacKay - Oct 8, 2016
    Ah! Fludfenutta ya gatta make yaself a sandwich with sum peanut butta, and put it on Wunda bread with a frappe or some tawnic. Pissah!
    Crabby Grilled Cheese Sandwich Recipe

    Crabby Grilled Cheese Sandwich

    Sherry Blizzard @akflurry

    This creation came from a combination of two recipes from two different local restaurants. I love all things seafood and cheese and what a fabulous combination these seafoods make when...

    Summer Picnic Sandwich Recipe

    Summer Picnic Sandwich

    Suzanne Banfield @SBcooks

    This sandwich holds up very well in a cooler and seems to get more flavorful after a couple of hours when the ingredients have melded together. Cut a big wedge,...

    Chicken Joe Wraps Recipe

    Chicken Joe Wraps

    David Henson @Davethechef

    This was an experiment gone awesome!!!