Overstuffed Reuben Sandwich

Lou Kostura


I really love corned beef and cabbage, my recipe for that is also posted in my recipe box along with instructions on how to brine (corn) your own brisket, however I just like nothing more than making Reuben Sammy's with the left over corned beef. Once again if you have the time and room in your fridge try brineing your own well worth it for the flavor.

I believe the cast iron skillet is the key to success with this sandwich. Also the slow cook, may not be the traditional way but it comes out perfect 100% of the time.

Serve with Thousand Island or Russian Dressing on side.


☆☆☆☆☆ 0 votes

15 Min
40 Min
Pan Fry


Add to Grocery List

2/3 lb
corned beef sliced
16 oz
sauerkraut drained and squeezed of juice
8 slice
swiss cheese
4 slice
jewish rye bread
1/2 stick
butter, unsalted
thousand island dressing
dill pickle
potato chips, whole

How to Make Overstuffed Reuben Sandwich


  • 1Assemble sandwiches by starting with 2 slices of swiss cheese on each side of sandwich. add 4 oz. squeezed sauerkraut on top cheese, split cornded beef for the 2 sandwiches and add on top. Add 4 more oz. sauerkraut. 2 more slices cheese, and top bread
  • 2melt 1/4 stick butter in cast iron skillet (heat at low) carefully add 2 sandwiches and cover for approx. 20 minutes or until bread is toasted nicely
  • 3add additional 1/4 stick butter, melt and flip sandwiches onto melted butter. again cook about 20 minutes covered or until everything is heated thru, cheese melted and toasted nicely
  • 4serve with pickle slices, thousand island dressing, and some potato chips...............enjoy

Printable Recipe Card

About Overstuffed Reuben Sandwich

Course/Dish: Sandwiches
Main Ingredient: Beef
Regional Style: Irish
Other Tag: Heirloom

Show 9 Comments & Reviews

Who Invented The Sandwich? Recipe

Who Invented the Sandwich?

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

In 1660, Edward Montagu, of England, was made an Earl. When one is made an Earl, they take the name of a city to complete their title. Edward Montagu had...

Bye Bye Boring Sandwiches, Hello Flavor Recipe

Bye Bye Boring Sandwiches, Hello Flavor

Kitchen Crew

Sandwiches are go-to for me. They can be on the lighter side if I'm looking for a small meal. Or, they can be loaded for something a bit heartier. Whenever...