Penny's Sweet Potato Casserole

Penny's Sweet Potato Casserole Recipe

No Photo

Have you made this?

 Share your own photo!

Penny Burdge


After using the same sweet potato recipe for 30+ years, this Thanksgiving (2012) I decided to try something different. My usual recipe uses quartered small sweet potatoes,a spicy/slighty sweet sauce of brown sugar, cinnamon and nutmeg, butter and both lemons and orange juice.

I looked through all the sweet potato casserole recipes on this site (and - but I just couldn't find one that seemed to "fit" my family. Couldn't be too sweet and had to have a zing of citrus. So this is what I devised from multiple recipes. We loved it, especially the zip from the citrus zests.


★★★★★ 1 vote

1 Hr
35 Min


Add to Grocery List

8 medium
sweet potatoes
1/4 c
dark brown sugar
2 large
eggs, slight beaten
1/4 c
evaporated milk or half and half
1/4 c
fresh orange juice
1 tsp
pure vanilla extract
6 Tbsp
very soft butter
1/4 tsp
freshly grated nutmeg
1/2 tsp
zest from a medium-large orange


1/4 c
all-purpose flour
4 Tbsp
very cold butter
6 Tbsp
dark brown sugar
1/2 c
chopped pecans
1/2 tsp
ground cinnamon
1/4 tsp
freshly grated nutmeg
zest from a medium large lemon

How to Make Penny's Sweet Potato Casserole


  • 1Clean and wrap the sweet potatoes in aluminum foil. Bake in a 350 degree oven until soft, about 40-45 minutes. Remove from oven, remove foil and allow to cool until they cool enough to handle, but are still warm. Remove the skins.
  • 2In a medium bowl, whisk together the eggs, milk, vanilla, orange juice.
  • 3Put the sweet potatoes in a large bowl and hand mash with the soft butter, spices and brown sugar. Blend in the egg mixture. Stir in the orange zest. Place the sweet potato mixture in a 9" x 13" buttered casserole.
  • 4Make the topping by cutting the butter into the flour in a small bowl until you have pea-sized pieces. add the spices and pecans. Stir in the lemon zest.
  • 5Sprinkle the topping evenly over the sweet potatoes and bake for about 30 minutes until the topping is browned and crunchy.
  • 6*Note - if you like very smooth potatoes, in step 3 you can use a hand mixer to whip up the sweet potato mixture. We tend to like more texture to our food, so I just hand mash.

Printable Recipe Card

About Penny's Sweet Potato Casserole

Course/Dish: Potatoes
Main Ingredient: Potatoes
Regional Style: American

Leave a Comment

22 Spudding Awesome Potato Recipes

22 Spudding Awesome Potato Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Everyone loves potatoes, and these recipes are crazy delicious. From main meals to side dishes, these potato recipes scream comfort food!

27 Easy Camping Recipes

27 Easy Camping Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Getting ready for a weekend camping trip? Here are 27 easy, no-hassle, camping-friendly recipes that everyone will love!