Texan Pepper-Sharp Mac and Cheese

1
Meredith Seymour

By
@MerryCurie

This is a VERY heavily modified version of Ina Garten's mac and cheese. Pretty much changed everything except the ratios of total cheese, amount of pepper, and milk and butter measurements. The rest I let my brain just kind of go wild with it.

This recipe can easily be halved, for two to four people, or tripled for a catering event. Both proportions taste wonderful and I have had a ton of compliments when I've catered it for my fiance's bowling buddies. They beg for it now when they have a potluck. :) I hope you enjoy it!

Rating:

☆☆☆☆☆ 0 votes

Serves:
6-8
Prep:
30 Min
Cook:
30 Min
Method:
Bake

Ingredients

  • MAKE IT GLUTEN FREE (LIKE I HAVE TO) BY USING GF FLOUR AND PASTA!

  • 1 bottle
    olive oil
  • 1 jar(s)
    salt
  • 1 lb
    elbow macaroni, rotini, or other pasta
  • 1 qt
    2% milk
  • 6 Tbsp
    butter
  • 1/2 c
    all-purpose flour
  • 1/2 tsp
    black pepper
  • 10 oz
    extra sharp or sharp cheddar, shredded
  • 10 oz
    pepper jack cheese, shredded
  • ·
    if you want, breadcrumbs, extra cheese, etc to top the baking dish with.
  • FOR RECIPE AS WRITTEN: A 9X13 PAN WILL BE REQUIRED. FOR HALF, A 9X9. FOR TRIPLE, YOU NEED A DISPOSABLE FOIL/BUFFET TRAY. WE FOUND THEM AT WALMART.

How to Make Texan Pepper-Sharp Mac and Cheese

Step-by-Step

  1. Preheat your oven to 375F.
  2. In a 4qt saucepan (or larger), salt the water liberally, and bring to a rolling boil. Pour in about 1/4 cup of olive oil. Add the noodle of your choice, and check the pasta 2 minutes before the earliest time listed on the package. the outside should be soft, but the inside should be MORE than al dente. It should be firm and hard to bite. Immediately remove pot from heat, strain for a few minutes, and then dump it into your pan to cool down, spreading it out so it won't clump together.
  3. Wipe out the pan with a towel or paper towel to get rid of any starchy residue. From there, heat the 6tbsp butter until all the way melted. Add the flour. Whisk continuously, cooking on medium until the mixture begins to foam slightly and it takes on a slight "nutty" smell.
  4. Once you get to that "nutty" smell, turn the heat to low immediately begin to slowly pour in the milk. At this point the roux will usually congeal and the mixture will look horrible. You will wonder, what the heck did I do? But never fear-you just need to get the milk heated up enough so the butter melts and the flour can begin thickening. Cook on low until all lumps are dissolved and the mixture is an ivory color. Immediately remove from heat and add your cheeses.
  5. Keep stirring until your cheese is mostly melted. Return to buner, heat on low until everything is smoothly incorporated into a cheese sauce. Remove from heat, stir in black pepper.
  6. If your noodles will fit in the pot you've chosen with the cheese sauce, put them in and gently fold everything in until combined. If not, pour the sauce over the noodles in the pan, and fold everything in there. Now, you can be as creative as you want when topping your mac and cheese. Bacon, pulled pork, pepperoni, pastrami, chips of all kinds, buttered breadcrumbs, or just plain cheese.
  7. For a 9x13", bake about 30-40 minutes until it's bubbling all the way through and toppings are crunchy.
    A 9x9" only goes for about 25-35 minutes. The 3 batch monster in the giant buffet pan takes about an hour to an hour and a half.

Printable Recipe Card

About Texan Pepper-Sharp Mac and Cheese




Leave a Comment

8 From-Scratch Tomato Sauce Recipes

8 From-Scratch Tomato Sauce Recipes


While we’re all for jarred Italian sauce, making tomato sauce from scratch is quite simple. Spending Sunday letting sauce simmer on the stove will turn a basic pasta dinner into a restaurant-quality meal. If you’re looking to up your next pasta night, give one of these 8 from-scratch tomato sauce recipes a try. Add a […]

7 Tuna Casserole Recipes

7 Tuna Casserole Recipes


Since the 1950s, tuna noodle casserole has been infamously gracing dinner tables throughout the United States. Either loved or hated, this family-friendly recipe has been handed down through generations. While there is the tried-and-true version, many have “jazzed up” mom’s tuna noodle casserole recipe to make it better than ever! From the traditional tuna casserole […]

20 Easy Labor Day Recipes

20 Easy Labor Day Recipes


No one wants to do hard work on Labor Day. The last thing anyone wants to do is spend their day in the kitchen making difficult dishes. That’s where these easy Labor Day recipes come in. Macaroni salad, dump peach cobbler, and marinated grilled chicken kabobs are effortless summer favorites anyone can make. While they […]