Eggnog Monte Cristos

Pat Duran


This recipe is revised and added to from Book 3 of Kitchen Chatter. The one sent out to several of you- Just a little different you can pencil in if you like it's on page 93. Hope you like these new additions. But both versions are very good!
Recipe may sound complicated -but it's not really just a lot of explain' Lucy! hee-hee.


★★★★★ 1 vote

12 mini or 4 whole
20 Min
15 Min
Pan Fry


Add to Grocery List

2 Tbsp
honey mustard
2 Tbsp
9 slice
white sandwiches bread,crust removed*
4 slice
swiss cheese
2 slice
gouda cheese*
6 slice
leftover turkey or deli turkey
6 slice
leftover ham or deli smoked ham
1/2 c
1 pinch
each nutmeg and cinnamon
3 Tbsp
2 tsp
granulated sugar
1/2 tsp
vanilla extract
powdered sugar for dusting, if desired
cranberry sauce, for serving*

How to Make Eggnog Monte Cristos


  • 1Note: all asterisks* are new to this recipe on page 93 of book #3 You ordered from me for 8 dollars.
    Mix the mustard and mayonnaise in a small bowl . Lay out 3 slices of the crust-less bread. Brush each slice with some of the mixture.
    Top each slice with 1 slice each of the Swiss cheese, turkey, ham and 1/2 slice of gouda. Cover with another slice of bread and brush with mixture; top each sandwich with another slice each as above..Brush the remaining 3 bread slices with the mixture and place mustard side down on top of the sandwiches.
  • 2Wrap each sandwich tightly with plastic wrap, to keep them compact.(squished) Chill in refrigerator at least 30 minutes and up to 6 hours.
  • 3Whisk eggnog, nutmeg, vanilla,sugar,and cinnamon in a shallow dish or pie plate. Unwrap the sandwiches and dip in the eggnog mixture, turning to coat both sides throughly.
    Melt 1/2 the butter in a large nonstick skillet or electric skillet over medium heat. Add the sandwiches and cook until they are golden. 3-4 minutes. Add remaining butter, flip the sandwiches and brown until golden, about 3 more minutes.
    Cut sandwiches into quarters. Dust with powdered sugar and serve with heated cranberry sauce for dipping.

Printable Recipe Card

About Eggnog Monte Cristos

Course/Dish: Chicken, Turkey, Sandwiches
Main Ingredient: Dairy
Regional Style: American
Other Tags: Quick & Easy, For Kids, Healthy

Show 13 Comments & Reviews

15 Easy Chicken Dinner Recipes

15 Easy Chicken Dinner Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Craving an easy weeknight meal? Look no further. Check out these simply irresistible ways to dress up chicken for a delicious (and easy) dinner recipe!

13 Cluckin' Great Chicken Recipes For Tonight's Dinner

13 Cluckin' Great Chicken Recipes for Tonight's Dinner

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Need some inspiration for tonight's dinner? Try one of these 13 cluckin' great chicken recipes.

Winner, Winner Have An Easy Chicken Dinner Tonight Recipe

Winner, Winner Have an Easy Chicken Dinner Tonight

Kitchen Crew

Chicken is my go-to when I just can't figure out what to make for dinner. Whenever I find myself wondering what to make, I grab a package at the market...