Perfect Peanut Butter Butterfinger Pie

linda gable


I combined several recipes for Butterfinger pie and peanut butter pie and then added my own special touches. The result was an absolutely perfect pie! Warning: it is extremely rich but addicting. Even those who proclaim it to be too rich keep going back for "just one more bite!"

★★★★★ 5 votes
30 Min
3 Hr
No-Cook or Other

Blue Ribbon Recipe

Notes from the Test Kitchen:
Attention all Butterfinger fans, this pie will be your go-to dessert! It's very simple to make and packs a punch of peanut-buttery flavor. Each creamy bite is filled with bits of crunchy Butterfinger goodness. The cream cheese adds a little tanginess. We chose an Oreo crust and it paired well with the chocolate of the candy bar. This is crazy good!


graham cracker or chocolate pie crust, storebought or homemade (may used crushed oreos, shortbread cookies, peanut butter cookies, etc. to make crust if you prefer)
1 pkg
cream cheese, at room temperature; 8 oz.
1/2 c
creamy peanut butter
2 tsp
pure vanilla extract
1 1/2 c
powdered suger
1 bag(s)
12.5 oz. fun size butterfinger candy bars, coarsely chopped to garnish the top of the pie (i reserve 2 of the chopped candy bars to garnish the top of the pie.)
8 oz
container frozen whipped topping (cool whip), thawed
chocolate bar to grate or shave on top, opt.

How to Make Perfect Peanut Butter Butterfinger Pie


  • 1Beat cream cheese and peanut butter in large mixing bowl until smooth. Add vanilla and mix well. Beat in powdered sugar until thoroughly incorporated.
  • 2Stir in all but two of the chopped Butterfinger bars. Fold in whipped topping. Spread mixture into crust.
  • 3Grate or shave as much chocolate as desired on top. Sprinkle with reserved chopped Butterfinger bars. Refrigerate at least three or four hours before serving. Can be frozen.

Printable Recipe Card

About Perfect Peanut Butter Butterfinger Pie

Course/Dish: Pies, Candies, Chocolate
Main Ingredient: Sugar
Regional Style: American
Collection: Summer Desserts!
Other Tag: Quick & Easy