Rose Mary Mogan


I wanted to create a VERY SPECIAL DESSERT for my husband for Father's Day to show him just how much I appreciate him. This is the dessert I came up with. I already have a Peanut Butter Pie recipe posted that he loves, so this one had to EXCEED the pie.

I made the crust using Peanut Butter cookie mix, then I added peanuts to add crunch, and Peanut Butter Chips to add extra flavor, then filled it with mini Reese's pieces, used Caramel Condensed milk & Light & Dark Brown Sugar, as well as Butterscotch Pudding to achieve that golden Caramel color. HE LOVED IT, it's his new favorite. We love it


☆☆☆☆☆ 0 votes

12 or more depending on portion size
55 Min
1 Hr 55 Min


Add to Grocery List


2 c
peanut butter cookie mix (i used betty crocker)
3 Tbsp
extra virgin olive oil (evoo)
2 Tbsp


4 pkg
cream cheese, softened 8 oz. each
11/2 c
creamy peanut butter
1/2 c
light brown sugar
2/3 c
dark brown sugar
1 can(s)
condensed milk not evaporated (caramel flavor)
1 c
chopped peanuts
1 Tbsp
vanilla bean extract
1 box
butterscotch instant pudding 3.4 oz size
1 pkg
peanut butter chips, 11 oz.
2 Tbsp
wondra flour
5 large
eggs,room temperature
1 c
sour cream


1 1/2 c
sour cream
3 Tbsp
1 tsp
each vanilla bean paste & lemon juice


snack size reeses cups cut in half
mini reeses peanut butter cups
1/4 c
reese's peanut butter dessert topping



  • 1Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.This is most of the main ingredients used in the recipe.
  • 2Add the crust ingredients to a small bowl and stir to blend together. Then pour into a 9 inch springform pan, and press crumb mixture evenly in the bottom and up the sides of the pan. Then place in preheated 350 degree F. oven and bake for 8- 10 minutes, Remove and set aside to cool till needed.
  • 3Using a large mixing bowl,I used a stand mixer, add in the softened cream cheese and peanut Butter, and beat until creamy and smooth.
  • 4Then add in both brown sugars and the condensed caramel milk, and beat until completely blended together.
  • 5Now add in the eggs, one at a time, beating well after each has been added.
  • 6Combine the Pudding and flour together then pour into the cream cheese peanut Butter mixture & beat until well blended.
  • 7Dust the peanut butter chips with about one Tablespoon of flour, then pour into cream cheese batter, add in the chopped peanuts, vanilla Bean extract, & beat or stir with a large spoon, until blended together. Dusting the chips with flour prevents them from sinking to the bottom of the cheesecake during baking.
  • 8Now you can add the 24 mini cups to the batter by stirring them in or do as I did, and push them randomly into the cheesecake batter.
  • 9Then cover top with enough remaining batter to within an inch and a half from top of pan. NOTICE: I HAD ENOUGH REMAINING BATTER TO MAKE AN EXTRA SERVING SIZE CHEESE CAKE,WHICH BAKES IN 45 MINUTES.
  • 10Wrap the bottom of the cheesecake pan with a triple layer of aluminum foil. Then place the cheesecake pan into a much larger pan and carefully pour boiling hot water around the base of the cheesecake, to at least 1 and a half inches deep. Note: I put the pan in the oven FIRST, BEFORE CAREFULLY ADDING THE HOT WATER.
  • 11Bake in preheated 325 degrees F. for 1 hour and a half. Then turn off oven, open the door slightly but leave the cheesecake in oven for 15 minutes.This is the amount of batter I had before filling the pan.
  • 12Then make the sour cream topping by combining all the ingredients in a small bowl, while the cake is in the oven. After 15 minutes, spread the sour cream topping over the top of the cake.
  • 13Leave the cake in the oven for an additional 45 minutes with the oven still turned off. Then remove cheesecake and allow to sit at room temperature for at least 1 and a half hours before putting in the fridge.
  • 14Now top the cake with the sprinkles and the snack size peanut butter cup, cut in half and arrange as desired.
  • 15Refrigerate at least 6 hours or over night before serving.
  • 16Before serving remove the sides of the spring form pan, then cut into serving size pieces. I added a chocolate syrup to a long platter then added the cheesecake slices.
  • 17This is what the cake looked like once I removed the sides of the springform pan.
  • 18This is what the cut cheesecake looks like.
  • 19This is the extra serving size that I gave away. It only needed 45 minutes to bake, and I did not use a water bath for this one because of the time it needed to bake. I had not added the sour cream topping or sprinkles before I took the picture..

Printable Recipe Card


Show 14 Comments & Reviews

Food Will Be The Star At Your July 4th Bbq Recipe

Food Will Be the Star at Your July 4th BBQ

Kitchen Crew

Make sure you've made a run for propane or charcoals... Fourth of July is next week! I'm gearing up to host a party. I've pulled together recipes that'll make any...

25 No-bake Dessert Recipes That Are Bringing Sexy Back

25 No-Bake Dessert Recipes That Are Bringing Sexy Back

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Not only are these no-bake desserts super easy to make, but these recipes are incredibly tempting and sure to satisfy your cravings!

Pinterest Pass Or Fail: S'more Pie Pops Recipe

Pinterest Pass or Fail: S'More Pie Pops

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Seriously, who doesn't love to eat food from a stick? With warmer weather and outdoor adventures upon us, these S'More Pie Pops from caught our eye. They'd be a...