Halloween Spooky Eyeballs

Crystal ~


A fun Halloween candy treat for a party or for gifts. For extra ghoulish effect, you can use crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy, giving the eyeballs a bit of crunch when bitten into. This makes a lot of candy so you can half the recipe, if needed.

These take a little time to make. Also, you must work quickly applying the red food coloring for the veins because the bark sets up fairly quick. The coating needs to be a bit soft so the red coloring can be sort of embedded in the coating. You can also use red gel or red tinted bark to pipe on the veins after the candy has set, instead.

☆☆☆☆☆ 0 votes
approximately 40-60
45 Min
30 Min
Stove Top


1½ sticks butter, unsalted
1½ cups of creamy peanut butter
4 cups powdered sugar
1 bag of plain chocolate mini m&m's
24 ounces of vanilla almond bark
red food coloring, red decorating gel, or tinted bark
¼-½ cup melted chocolate chips

How to Make Halloween Spooky Eyeballs


  • 1In a large microwave safe mixing bowl, combine the butter and peanut butter. Melt mixture in the microwave for about 2 minutes until butter and peanut butter is melted; stir the mixture a few times during the microwaving process to combine ingredients.
  • 2Remove the bowl from the microwave and stir in the powdered sugar. You may need to use your hands to thoroughly incorporate it.
  • 3Roll the mixture into small 1-inch balls while mixture is still warm. If mixture becomes too crumbly, put the bowl back into the microwave and warm it up some more.
  • 4Place balls on 2 cookie sheets lined with wax paper. Refrigerate or freeze for about 30 minutes. Meanwhile….
  • 5Melt the vanilla almond bark in a double boiler.
  • 6Bring out one cookie sheet of peanut butter balls at a time. Using a tooth pick, dip peanut butter ball in the coating and then gently tap the ball on the side of the pan to remove excess coating. Then Use a small knife to try and scrape a little of the excess coating off the bottom to help prevent a big glob on the bottom. Place ball back on cookie sheet and twist the toothpick gently to remove it.
  • 7Gently press an M&M on top of the toothpick in the coated peanut butter ball hole while coating is still warm.
  • 8Using a tooth pick, dip it into red coloring and add squiggly lines into coating to make blood shot eyes. (you can use some prepared red icing out of a tube, if you wish)
  • 9Melt the chocolate chips in a small microwave safe bowl. Using a toothpick, dot the centers of each M&M. Chill candy on a cookie sheet until firm. Store in an air tight container.

Printable Recipe Card

About Halloween Spooky Eyeballs

Course/Dish: Candies
Main Ingredient: Sugar
Regional Style: American
Collection: Halloween Treats