Not Your Mama's Cookies!

Beth Colon


I was in search of the perfect cookie base in order to build my perfect cookie. Printed in the NY times, a few years ago someone asked all of the best bakers what their secrets were and put together HIS perfect cookie. Well, I took his base and added my own spin on it. These cookies could also be called "willpower cookies"! After you make them, you let the batter sit in the fridge for over 36 hours!! (Trust me it's worth it!!) AND then once you do bake them, you need some willpower not to eat all of them! I hope you give this recipe a chance, you won't be sorry.

Blue Ribbon Recipe

The perfect sweet & salty flavor combo! We loved these cookies... and think you will too. Test Kitchen Avatar The Test Kitchen


★★★★☆ 26 votes

depends on the size of cookie. I got 40.
20 Min
20 Min


  • 2 c
    cake flour
  • 1 3/4 c
    bread flour
  • 1 1/4 tsp
    baking soda
  • 1 1/2 tsp
    baking powder
  • 1 1/2 tsp
  • 2 1/2 stick
    butter, room temperature ( not margarine)
  • 1 1/4 c
    light brown sugar, packed
  • 1 1/4 c
  • 2
    eggs, large, room temperature
  • 2 Tbsp
  • 5 oz
    ghiradelli dark chocolate (60 - 80% cacao) squares ( or one bag )
  • 5 oz
    reese's peanut butter chips (half a bag)
  • ·
    mini pretzel sticks
  • ·
    sea salt

How to Make Not Your Mama's Cookies!


  1. Allow butter and eggs to come to room temp. I usually take them out about 2 hours before I'm ready to use.

    Chop chocolate squares into rough chunks, set aside.

    Mix dry ingredients (flours, baking soda/powder and salt) together and set aside
  2. In mixer, cream together sugars and butter for about 5 minutes, until they are light and super creamy. (seems like a long time, but this is worth it) Add eggs one at a time and blend after each addition until well mixed. Stir in vanilla.
    Switch mixer to low and slowly add in the dry ingredients just until mixed in.
    Fold in the chocolate chunks and peanut butter chips. (Walnuts or almonds or pecans would be awesome in this!! I couldn't add any bc no one in my family likes them, except me)
  3. At this point, this is where the willpower comes in!! Place a piece of plastic wrap directly on top of batter and then place another piece of wrap over the top of bowl and refrigerate for 36-72 hours!!!! I know, I know. But this step is well worth it. It gives all of the flavors time to "marinate" and get to know one another. The cookies are rich and so flavorful. It adds caramel notes of flavor because of the butter and brown sugar...... yum, I'm drooling lol
  4. Finally, the day is here and you can bake them!!

    Preheat oven to 350*

    **During cooking process, keep the batter in the fridge to keep cold and always use a COLD baking sheet.

    Line baking pan with parchment paper.

    Break pretzel sticks. I broke mine into half and then half again. But it's up to you and it depends on the size of your sticks. You don't want them too small, bc you want to be able to taste them.

    Using an ice cream scoop or a tablespoon, scoop out dough. If it is too hard, run the scoop/spoon under hot water for a second. Shape dough into ball and place on prepared cookie sheet. Don't crowd the cookies, bc they do spread.
    Take your broken pretzels and stick them in the ball at random places. I used 4-5 pieces in each cookie. (you add the pretzel pieces now instead of when you make the batter, bc you don't want them to get mushy and still have a crunch)

    Sprinkle sea salt on the top of each cookie (this just takes the cookie up up and away!!)
  5. Place cookies into oven. Cook for 15-20 minutes. Check on them at 15 minutes. Mine took all of the 20 minutes to cook. Let cool for a few minutes then transfer to wire rack to finish cooling......if you can wait, lol

    Finally you can enjoy the best cookie you've ever tasted! Try not to burn your mouth on the hot cookie!!

Printable Recipe Card

About Not Your Mama's Cookies!

Course/Dish: Cookies Other Snacks
Main Ingredient: Flour
Regional Style: American
Collection: 2012 Member's Choice

Show 96 Comments & Reviews

Fresh Corn Recipes That Make Tasty Side Dishes

Fresh Corn Recipes That Make Tasty Side Dishes

We’re not all lucky enough to have fields to grow fresh corn, but thankfully it’s abundant at the market. And while zucchini is one of the most popular summer veggies (even though it’s technically a fruit), I really think corn on the cob ranks at the top. I look forward to enjoying it each summer. […]

14 Refreshing Strawberry Lemonade Recipes

14 Refreshing Strawberry Lemonade Recipes

Nothing quite says summer like a refreshing glass of ice-cold strawberry lemonade. And now, with these easy 14 homemade strawberry lemonade recipes, you can make it for all your front-porch-sippin’ needs! Full of fresh strawberries and lemons, these recipes will be your go-to for drinks by the pool or in the backyard all summer long.

10 Ice Cream Sandwiches to Beat the Summer Heat

10 Ice Cream Sandwiches to Beat the Summer Heat

One of the summer staples is hearing the sound of the ice cream truck roaming the neighborhood and ice cream sandwiches are always on the menu. Vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate cookies they are a classic summer treat. These days, ice cream sandwiches have gotten a makeover and you don’t need the ice […]