Easter / Ostara Make a Wish Pie

Stormy Stewart


Every one thinks of a wish they want to come true in the months ahead and then gets a piece of pie. The one who finds a rabbit hiding inside gets their wish first. The one with the most eggs in their pie gets it second, and so on.

For smaller children omit the toy rabbit and just do chocolate eggs.

I take this to circle meetings on ostara

★★★★★ 1 vote
1 pie
No-Cook or Other


Add to Grocery List

readymade graham cracker crust
8 oz
cream cheese, room temperature
14 oz
eagle sweetened condensed milk
3/4 c
cold milk
1 pkg
(small) cheesecake flavor instant pudding mix
1 1/2 c
cool whip thawed
mini chocolate eggs
1 small
glass rabbit (less than an inch) use only with older kids or adults) and tell them about the prize.

How to Make Easter / Ostara Make a Wish Pie


  • 1In large bowl beat Cream Cheese until fluffy.
    Gradually beat in condensed milk until smooth.
    Add milk and pudding mix; beat on low speed until smooth.
    Spoon half of filling into crust.
    Place chocolate eggs evenly over filling add one small toy rabbit. Top with remaining filling.
    Chill 3 hours
  • 2NOTE: variation on this recipe. use white chocolate pudding and add malted milk balls and one chocolate egg. the chocolate egg wins first wish.
  • 3For young Children ... use Holiday marshmallow Candies or other soft Candies and do not add a toy!

Printable Recipe Card

About Easter / Ostara Make a Wish Pie

Course/Dish: Puddings, Candies, Chocolate
Main Ingredient: Dairy
Regional Style: American

Show 7 Comments & Reviews

How To Fold Ingredients Recipe

How to Fold Ingredients

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

The Just A Pinch Test Kitchen shows how to fold ingredients using whipped cream and chocolate pudding. Watch the "pinch tips" video here.

Make Foolproof Whipped Cream At Home Recipe

Make Foolproof Whipped Cream at Home

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Fresh whipped cream is so much better than the stuff you buy in a tub or a can and so easy to make. We prefer to sweeten our whipped cream...

Pinch Tips: How To Fold Ingredients Recipe

pinch tips: How to Fold Ingredients

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

The Just A Pinch Test Kitchen shows how to fold ingredients.