Real Recipes From Real Home Cooks ®

sugar free oreo ice cream pie

(1 rating)
Recipe by
Tina Brown
Woodstock, AL

My husband is diabetic and has a sweet tooth. Finding desserts that satisfy him without him being able to "taste" that it's sugar free has been a challenge. This pie was a huge hit with my entire family.

(1 rating)
yield 8 -12
prep time 1 Hr 35 Min

Ingredients For sugar free oreo ice cream pie

  • 1/2 gal
    sugar free vanilla ice cream, slightly softened
  • 1 pkg
    sugar free oreo cookies
  • 1 pkg
    cool-whip topping, softened
  • 1
    pie crust (graham cracker, oreo, or regular)

How To Make sugar free oreo ice cream pie

  • 1
    If you choose the traditional pie crust, bake according to directions and let cool. If you use graham cracker or cookie crust, go to step 2.
  • 2
    Carefully slice enough cookies in 1/2 to go around the outer rim of the pie for garnish. Place the rest of the cookies in a baggie, making sure to let out the excess air, then crush the cookies.
  • 3
    In a large bowl, with a wooden spoon, mix 1/2 of the ice cream and 1/2 of the crushed cookies together. Add the rest of the ice cream and crushed cookies a bit at a time until fully blended. BE SURE TO SET ASIDE A PINCH OF THE CRUSHED COOKIES TO GARNISH THE TOP OF YOUR PIE.
  • 4
    Pour the blended ice cream into the crust and smooth out. Place in the freezer for about 15 minutes to begin to harden.
  • 5
    Remove the pie from the freezer and top with the whole tub of Cool-Whip. Place the sliced cookies cut side down on the outer rim of the pie and sprinkle the rest of the pie with the reserved crushed cookies.
  • 6
    Return the pie to the freezer for at least 30 minutes, or until ready to serve.