Get the App
Recipes
Find a Recipe
Blue Ribbon Recipes
Pinch It!™ Feed
Browse Recipes
Editorial
Food Bites & Articles
Videos
What is a Blue Ribbon?
Meet the Test Kitchen
Community
Member Recipes
Groups
Sweepstakes
Contests
Shopping
My Friend's Old Fashioned Coconut Custard Pie
Javascript must be enabled.
Back
to Recipe
Upload a Photo
Photos of My Friend's Old Fashioned Coconut Custard Pie
Photo by
Kitchen Crew
@JustaPinch
Give a Thumbs Up
My Friend's Old-Fashioned Coconut Custard Pie ready to slice.
Photo by
Kitchen Crew
@JustaPinch
Give a Thumbs Up
Mix eggs and sugar well with a hand mixer.
Photo by
Kitchen Crew
@JustaPinch
Give a Thumbs Up
Add vanilla extract and coconut.
Photo by
Kitchen Crew
@JustaPinch
Give a Thumbs Up
Stir in the melted butter by hand.
Photo by
Kitchen Crew
@JustaPinch
Give a Thumbs Up
Add half and half mixture slowly to the egg/sugar mix.
Photo by
Kitchen Crew
@JustaPinch
Give a Thumbs Up
Add back to remaining half and half and stir until well combined.
Photo by
Kitchen Crew
@JustaPinch
Give a Thumbs Up
Dissolve corn starch in half and half.
Photo by
Kitchen Crew
@JustaPinch
Give a Thumbs Up
A slice of My Friend's Old-Fashioned Coconut Custard Pie on a plate.
Photo by
Kitchen Crew
@JustaPinch
Give a Thumbs Up
Baked pie on a cooling rack.
Photo by
Kitchen Crew
@JustaPinch
Give a Thumbs Up
Pour into pie crust and bake.
Photo by
Diana Perry
@Empebi
Give a Thumbs Up