Old Timey Caramel Icing

Renae McVay


I always had trouble making caramel icing before I got this recipe from a friend's mother. Putting the cold butter in last made all the difference for me. It tastes so good too!

pinch tips: How to Use Hand & Stand Mixers




12 or more


15 Min


30 Min


Stove Top


3 c
white granulated sugar
1 1/3 c
white whole milk
1 1/2 stick
cold butter
5 Tbsp
white granulated sugar

Directions Step-By-Step

Combine 3 cups sugar and milk in a heavy sauce pan on medium heat. Stir together for a few minutes. Allow to continue to heat.
While milk and sugar are heating, place a small black iron skillet on med. to med. high heat. Add the 5 tablespoons on sugar. Stir in the skillet until the sugar liquifies and then turns golden brown. It will be bubbling hot.
Now the milk and sugar should be very hot. Carefully pour in the browned sugar from the skillet. Whisk together and cook for about 15 minutes or until the mixture reached the very soft ball stage. (test by dropping a little off a spoon into a small glass of cool water. When a small soft ball forms, it's ready.)
Remove from heat and using an electric mixer, mix in 1 and 1/2 sticks cold butter...never margarine!
Continue to beat until cooled to spreading consistency.
If too thick, you can thin by beating in milk a tablespoon at a time.
Make sure your cake in completely cooled or this heavy icing may cause the top to split. It'll still taste super though!

About this Recipe

Course/Dish: Cakes
Main Ingredient: Sugar
Regional Style: Southern
Other Tag: Heirloom