Thousand and One Island Dressing

Sherry Peyton


We decided we had to have some Reuben sandwiches,so I set out on a quest to create a thousand island dressing worthy of such a meat. I came up with what we loved.And I'll throw in the sandwich recipe for free! Hope you give it a try. If you like this recipe, see others at my website:


★★★★★ 1 vote

15 Min


Add to Grocery List

1 c
1/4 c
very finely minced red sweet pepper
2 Tbsp
very finely minced shallot
1 Tbsp
heaping, sweet pickle relish
1 Tbsp
heaping, finely chopped pimento olives
1 Tbsp
1 Tbsp
chili sauce
1 Tbsp
fresh parsley, finely minced

How to Make Thousand and One Island Dressing


  • 1Place all together in a bowl and mix well. (Note: I placed the pickle relish in a small sieve and pressed out some of the liquid). Place in fridge for a couple of hours to let the flavors meld.
  • 2For a wonderful Reuben: For each sandwich: two slices Jewish rye bread. Butter once side of each and place under broiler until melted and lightly browned. Then on the untoasted side of one,slather with a TBSP or more of the 1000 Island dressing. Place about 1/3 of a pound of deli-quality corned beef on top.
  • 3Take sauerkraut which has been placed in a sieve and drained and place on top, about 1/2 c on each top of the corned beef. Cover this with finely sliced good quality swiss cheese (I used Ementhaler). Place on a broiler pan. Turn off the oven from the broiling. Place the sandwiches in the oven to let the cheese melt and the meat to warm a bit. Slather the other slice of bread with more 1000 Island dressings and place on top, slice in half and enjoy.

Printable Recipe Card

About Thousand and One Island Dressing

Course/Dish: Dressings
Other Tag: Quick & Easy
Hashtags: #sandwiches, #salads

Show 5 Comments & Reviews

Pinch Tips: How To Use A Whisk Recipe

pinch tips: How to Use a Whisk

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

The Just A Pinch Test Kitchen shows how to use a whisk.

17 Homemade Salad Dressings Recipe

17 Homemade Salad Dressings

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

It’s time to ditch those store-bought dressings! You’ll never believe how easy it is to make absolutely delicious homemade salad dressing - just check out these awesome recipes from home...