Chris' Favorite Honey Mustard Sauce

Leslie Coleman


My son was very particular about his Honey Mustard Sauce. This was the winning combination, after dozens of trials.

★★★★★ 1 vote
10 Min


1 c
hellman's mayonaisse
1 c
nance sharp & creamy mustard
1 Tbsp
a-1 hearty spicy steak sauce
1/2 c
2 Tbsp
1 Tbsp
fresh lemon juice

How to Make Chris' Favorite Honey Mustard Sauce


  • 1Over very low heat, mix Nance Sharp & Creamy Mustard and butter, until butter is melted and thoroughly incorporated into the mustard. (Mustard will separate from butter if heat is too high.)
  • 2Empty mixture into a small mixing bowl. Add cold fresh lemon juice and allow to cool slightly.
  • 3Add A-1 Sauce, mayonaisse and honey. Whip with a whisk or fork until all ingredients are incorporated.
  • 4Refrigerate in tightly closed container. (Consider storing in plastic soda bottles with tight tops.)
  • 5Hints:
    Serve with chicken cutlets.
    Spread on hot grilled ham & swiss cheese sandwiches.
    Add to egg salad mixture.
    Dip for fresh apple slices.
    My favorite: Dip for pretzel rods.

Printable Recipe Card

About Chris' Favorite Honey Mustard Sauce

Course/Dish: Dips, Spreads, Dressings
Other Tag: Quick & Easy
Hashtags: #honey, #sauce, #mustard