Super Creamy Macaroni Salad

Kelly Williams


I make several different kinds of macaroni salads, but this one is my hubby's favorite and the one I make when I need to please everybody! I finally took the time to write it down as I added, so putting it here for safe keeping and so next time I won't have to fiddle with it to get it right! Enjoy!
Photo by me. (It got chopped off, though!) :( I hope they start accepting larger photos soon!!!!


★★★★★ 2 votes

about 8
10 Min
10 Min


  • 2 1/2
    cups uncooked macaroni
  • SAUCE:

  • 2
    cups mayo
  • 1/3
    cup sweet pickle relish
  • 3
    tbl. sugar
  • 3
    tbl. sweet pickle juice from sweet butter pickles
  • 1
    tsp. regular salt
  • 1
    tsp. celery salt
  • 2
    tsp. regular table mustard
  • 2
    tbl. dried minced onion
  • *1
    tbl. milk

How to Make Super Creamy Macaroni Salad


  1. In large bowl, mix all sauce ingredients except milk, stirring well, set aside. Cook macaroni according to package directions. Drain, rinse with cold water to stop cooking and chill, drain again, and stir into sauce mixture. Chill in fridge for 30 minutes to one hour. Stir in 1 Tbl. milk to loosen and serve! Enjoy!
  2. ***SECRET TIP!
    Forgot to put this in here! After you drain your macaroni, put it in a small shallow bowl and pour 1/3-1/2 cup of milk over it. Keep stirring now and then and let the macaroni absorb all or most of the milk. This will take about 20-30 minutes, but WORTH IT. The pasta won't be soggy or anything, but will help GREATLY with stopping the sauce from soaking in too much and be dry. Just drain any excess milk before stirring into the sauce. You will then only have to add a TAD of mayo or milk to refresh the salad instead of a gallon more of mayo!

Printable Recipe Card

About Super Creamy Macaroni Salad

Course/Dish: Pasta Salads
Other Tag: Quick & Easy

Show 12 Comments & Reviews

Elevate The Pasta Salad At Your Next Cookout

Elevate the Pasta Salad at Your Next Cookout

Kitchen Crew

Cookout season is in full effect! My husband and I were looking at the calendar and realized we have a cookout nearly every weekend for the next few weeks. One...

15 Easy Pasta Salad Recipes

15 Easy Pasta Salad Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Besides being super simple to throw together, the great thing about pasta salad is you can customize it based on your favorite flavors. We've found 15 flavorful pasta salad recipes...

Pasta Salad & Macaroni Salad: Are They The Same Thing?

Pasta Salad & Macaroni Salad: Are They the Same Thing?

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Pasta salad and macaroni salad are both made with pasta so that makes them the same thing, right? Our customer service receives this comment/question a lot so we decided to...