Cookie Monster Pumpkin :D

Nicole P.


I like making different looking pumpkins and this one always gets lots of compliments LOL :)
Very easy to make as you can see!


☆☆☆☆☆ 0 votes

depends on the amount of cookies you make!
No-Cook or Other


  • ·
    pumpkin (any size)
  • ·
    blue paint
  • ·
    styrofoam balls
  • ·
    round black card stock, black paper or felt
  • ·
    toothpicks and glue

How to Make Cookie Monster Pumpkin :D


  1. Hollow out the pumpkin and cut out the mouth as show. (Once you finish painting the pumpkin)
    Glue black circles on Styrofoam balls
    What i usually do is push a toothpick into the pumpkin top for the eyes, remove and reinsert and remove again :) so you have your holes ready, now all you need to do is insert the toothpicks in the styrofoam balls (eyes) and push down into the pre-made pumpkin holes :)
  2. Getting your pumpkin ready for painting:
    Give your pumpkin a wash to remove any dirt or dust. The easiest is to use a damp cloth or wet-wipe, or with a hosepipe on the lawn. Don't scrub with a hard brush as you risk damaging the skin. Wipe with a dry cloth or paper towel, or leave to air dry
  3. Painting on a layer of sealer or varnish is optional, though it will help the paint to stick. (It's also said to slow down the evaporation of moisture from the pumpkin helping it to last longer, but really, painted pumpkins are temporary artworks.) Any type of general purpose sealer or acrylic medium ought to be okay, but if in doubt do a small test on the bottom of your pumpkin first.
  4. Acrylic paints (whether craft or artist's acrylics) work best, but if you've only poster paints or kids' paints do a test to see how they stick before getting the family involved. You likely will find the latter come off if it rains, if the pumpkin is handled too much or with wet hands but is otherwise okay.
  5. When you've finished, consider adding another layer of sealer or varnish to protect your painted pumpkin. A spray-on varnish makes this final stage easy, but remember you don't want to inhale any of it so read the instructions on the can and do it outside if possible.
  6. To avoid your cookies to have a small taste of pumpkin, i suggest you wrap them individually with plastic wrap :)

Printable Recipe Card

About Cookie Monster Pumpkin :D

Course/Dish: Other Non-Edibles
Main Ingredient: Non-Edible or Other
Regional Style: American
Other Tag: Quick & Easy

Leave a Comment

13 Time-saving Kitchen Gadgets

13 Time-Saving Kitchen Gadgets

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Everyone needs a few kitchen shortcuts. We've gathered 13 items that will save you time in the kitchen, and maybe your sanity too. Herb Scissors Saves space and time......

Pinch Tips: How To Keep Knives Sharp Like A Pro

pinch tips: How to Keep Knives Sharp Like a Pro

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Thanks to these tips from the Just A Pinch Test Kitchen your knives will always be sharp!

7 Tips For Black friday shopping

7 Tips for Black Friday Shopping

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

If you love a good bargain, chances are, you love Black Friday. The day after Thanksgiving is widely known as the nation’s single biggest shopping day all year long. True,...