OMG, That's a Good Turkey!

Omg, That's A Good Turkey! Recipe

No Photo

Have you made this?

 Share your own photo!

Beth French


I know everyone has already cooked their Thanksgiving turkey but some of us cook a turkey at Christmas as well so I thought I would post this recipe. I bought a 22 quart electric roaster this year because I wanted to make space in my oven for the many casseroles I make. I was so worried that the turkey would not turn out as well as a turkey cooked in the oven or deep fried because I have never used an electric roaster before. It turned out not only well, but to be the best turkey I ever put in my mouth!! Everyone at the table agreed that it was the moistest, juiciest turkey they had ever tasted and wanted to know how I had cooked it. It was one of the easiest turkeys I have ever cooked because it does not require basting. Deep fried turkeys are usually soaked in brine (a water and salt solution) and I decided to brine this turkey before roasting it. I wasn't sure if it was the right thing to do or not with an electric roaster but I took a gamble. It turned out divine and you know what, it's the first year I have not been left with dry leftover turkey for days and days! I did not take a picture of this bird but I should have as it was golden brown and beautiful! Everything I read about electric roasters said the the turkey would not be brown but it was! Maybe it's because I coated both the top and underneath the skin with butter, spices and olive oil.

There is one thing I should point out. The instructions that came with the roaster said to cook the turkey at 4 and 1/2 hours for an 18 pound bird but I did not follow these instructions because the turkey had already been soaked in brine. If cooked as instructed, the turkey would have been completely overcooked. One other thing I would also like to point out that although the 24 and 1/2 hour prep time may seem cumbersome, the reason it takes so long is because the step of soaking the turkey in the brine overnight. An additional 3 and 1/2 hours of this time is the time the turkey spends in the roaster with no attention at all needed. The actual hands on prep time is closer to 45 minutes including preparing the brine and preparing the turkey with the oil and butter mixture.


★★★★★ 1 vote

24 Hr 30 Min
3 Hr 30 Min


Add to Grocery List

frozen, 18 pound butterball turkey, partially thawed for three days in the refrigerator
for the brine ( you need an 8 guart pot and 5 gallon bucket)
orange, cut in half (or lemon or both)
slices of fresh peeled ginger about the size of a quarter
3 Tbsp
1 c
kosher salt
6 inch sprigs of rosemary, left whole
cloves of garlic, smashed
2 Tbsp
soy sauce
1 Tbsp
worchestershire sauce
1 tsp
poultry seasoning
3 inch sprigs of thyme, left whole
1 tsp
sage or several fresh sprigs of sage
to season the turkey
stick of butter, melted
1/4 c
extra virgin olive oil
1/2 c
chopped fresh parsley
1/8 c
thyme leaves
fresh sage leaves, chopped
1/4 tsp
greek seasoning
salt and fresh ground pepper

How to Make OMG, That's a Good Turkey!


  • 1For the brine, add all food ingredients from the orange to the sage with the exception of the turkey into an 8 quart pot and boil for 30 minutes. Let cool.
  • 2Remove turkey from package and rinse well. Place breast down into the 5 gallon plastic pail.
  • 3Pour brine over the turkey and add ice and water until the brine covers the turkey. Let the turkey sit in the brine for 24 hours. Over the next 24 hours, keep a check and add ice, if needed, to keep the turkey cold.
  • 4After 24 hours, remove the turkey from the brine and place on counter.
  • 5Loosen the skin from the bird by running your hand under the skin in all directions as far as you can.
  • 6Melt one stick of butter in a bowl and add 1/4 Cup of extra virgin olive oil once the butter has been melted.
  • 7Add chopped fresh parsley, thyme, Greek seasoning and sage leaves to the butter and olive oil mixture and stir until blended.
  • 8Spoon butter mixture under the skin of the turkey and on the outside of the turkey and rub in well. Salt and pepper the turkey skin lightly.
  • 9Place turkey, neck, liver and gizzard in roaster if making giblet gravy, put the lid on and set the dial for 350 degrees.
  • 10Cook for 3 and 1/2 hours and do not remove the lid during this time because you will loose your steam and it will take a long time to build back up to the 350 temperature and this will mess up the amount of time it takes to cook the turkey. I know you will be tempted to peek but do not!!! This is very important!
  • 11After three and one half hours, remove the lid and allow the steam to escape for a few minutes. Insert a meat thermometer into the fattest part of the breast and thigh and make sure that the turkey's temperature is at 180 degrees.
  • 12Remove the turkey, carve the bird and enjoy!

Printable Recipe Card

About OMG, That's a Good Turkey!

Course/Dish: Turkey

Leave a Comment

Healthy, Flavorful Recipes For The New Year

Healthy, Flavorful Recipes for the New Year

Kitchen Crew

The holiday season is a time for indulgence... and, oh boy, did I indulge. I don't regret the pieces of cake and all the cookies, but it's time to reset...

8 Delicious Ground Turkey Recipes

8 Delicious Ground Turkey Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Ground turkey is a great way to make your favorite meals a bit healthier. These recipes are so tasty, you won't even miss the original!

The Do’s And Don’ts Of Stuffing A Turkey Recipe

The Do’s and Don’ts of Stuffing a Turkey

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Are you team stuffing or team dressing? Either way, there’s a right way and a wrong way to stuff your Thanksgiving bird. Check out this guideline you need to know...