Fresh Golden Egg Grilled Capicola Pepperoni Cheese Sandwich

Linda Schmidt


Love home made bread, pepperoni and grilled cheese sandwiches so decided the other day to do a spin on this childhood classic.

If you can not find the pepperoni cheese in your deli section you can replace thin sliced pepperoni and sharp cheddar cheese! Mine comes from NJ and frozen cause I can not find it here in my area :-).

This is so yummy had one 3 days in a row!! The pearl onion gives the bite a crunch but if you don't like onions you can omit it as I have had it both ways and both are just as yummy.


★★★★★ 2 votes

10 Min
4 Hr


Add to Grocery List

3/4 c
water, warm
1 1/2 tsp
6 Tbsp
vegetable oil
4 Tbsp
3 c
bread flour
1 pkg
fleischmann's rapid rise dry yeast
4 slice
capicola ham (deli)
2 slice
pepperoni cheese (deli)
1-2 small
white pearl onion (sliced)
blue bonnet margarine spread

How to Make Fresh Golden Egg Grilled Capicola Pepperoni Cheese Sandwich


  • 1Put first 7 ingredients in bread machine in order listed.
  • 2Turn on and let machine make and bake the bread.
  • 3When cool slice and freeze remainder of bread not used as it will only stay fresh for 2 days.
  • 4Heat skillet on med while preparing sandwich to be grilled.
  • 5Butter 2 slices of bread. Lay one slice butter side down on hot skillet. Top with 2 slices of ham, 2 slices of pepperoni cheese, pearl onion and 2 slices of ham and other piece of bread butter side up.
  • 6Fry both sides of the sandwich, slice and Enjoy!

Printable Recipe Card

About Fresh Golden Egg Grilled Capicola Pepperoni Cheese Sandwich

Course/Dish: Pork, Sandwiches
Other Tag: Quick & Easy

Show 10 Comments & Reviews

11 Recipes To Bring You Luck In The New Year

11 Recipes to Bring You Luck in the New Year

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Start the new year on the right foot by making one of these lucky recipes.

Pork Tenderloin, It's What's For Dinner Recipe

Pork Tenderloin, It's What's for Dinner

Kitchen Crew

Ever wander through the meat department at the grocery store and see a pork tenderloin on sale? Everyone knows you can throw pork chops in a bag, shake them around...