Cottage Pie with a Twist

Andy Anderson !


This is an excellent dish to serve on those cold Autumn evenings, when the wind is howling out of the north, and the clouds, low and gray, are rushing across the sky. There's a certain smell to the air... Could that be the promise of snow?
Cottage pie is a traditional English dish, and this is what the recipe is based on. I've added a few of my own touches... Like adding carrots, sweet potatoes, and garlic to the topping. As a matter of fact, this dish just begs for some experimentation.


★★★★★ 2 votes

40 Min
20 Min


  • 1/2 lb
    yukon gold potatoes, peeled & medium diced
  • 1/2 lb
    sweet potatoes, peeled & medium diced
  • 1/4 lb
    fresh carrots
  • 5 clove
    fresh garlic, medium sized
  • 4 Tbsp
    sweet butter, unsalted
  • 1/2 lb
    ground chuck
  • 1/2 lb
    ground pork
  • 1
    yellow onion, medium sized, diced small
  • 1 lb
    mushrooms, button or cremini, trimmed and thinly sliced
  • 1/4 c
    tomato puree
  • 1 1/2 Tbsp
    worcestershire sauce
  • 1 Tbsp
    hungarian paprika
  • 1 tsp
    cayenne pepper, or to taste
  • 1 c
    hot water
  • ·
    salt and pepper, to taste

How to Make Cottage Pie with a Twist


  1. Place the potatoes, carrots, and two cloves of the garlic into a pot of boiling, salted water. Cook until vegetables are tender, about 15 minutes.

    Note: The time here is based on how hot the water is, and how small you cubed your veggies. Have a fork close at hand. If the fork penetrates the veggie with little resistance, they're done, regardless of the time.
  2. Drain and discard water, and then use a masher to mash the vegetables until mostly smooth. Season with salt and pepper, add three tablespoons of butter and combine. Cover the bowl, and set out the way... you'll need them a bit later in the process

    Note: If you have a food processor, and you're willing to use it, then the mixing of the garlic, and the potatoes and carrots for the topping will go much smoother, and the results will be more consistent.

    Of course, there's a lot to be said for the mix-by-hand method... it makes the dish more rustic, and cottage pie by definition is rustic fare.
  3. Finely chop the remaining three garlic cloves and set aside in a small prep dish.

    Note: A quick way to peel the skin off a piece of garlic is to give is a good smack with the side of a wide kitchen knife... WACK! The skin falls right off.
  4. In a large skillet over medium-high heat, melt remaining tablespoon of butter, add the beef and pork, and then cook until browned, about 5 to 10 minutes.

    Note: As it's cooking, use a wooden spoon to break the mixture into small bits.
  5. Remove the beef from the pan (leave drippings in the pan), and set aside.

    Note: You want about 3 Tablespoons of drippings in the pan. If you have more than that, pour out the excess into a small bowl. Then, as you're cooking, if you need some more, you can always add it back into the pan. If you're using real lean cuts of meat, and you feel that you don't have enough pan drippings, then just add a bit of olive oil, as you're cooking... But don't overdo it.
  6. With the pan set to medium-high, add chopped onion, and cook in the drippings until translucent, about 5 minutes.

    Keep an eye on the pan, so the onions don't burn... I hate it when that happens.
  7. Add mushrooms, and cook (stirring occasionally) until golden, about 10 minutes.
  8. Add garlic, and cook until fragrant, about 1 minute.

    Remember during these last three steps (6,7,8) to keep the pan active. Stir, stir, stir. If things look they are cooking too fast, reduce the heat, or remove the pan for a minute to cool it down a bit.
  9. Return the browned beef/pork and any juices back to the pan, and stir in the tomato puree. Let cook an additional 2 minutes. Stir, stir, stir.
  10. Add the cayenne and paprika, and stir for about 1 minute.

    Note: Cayenne is a fairly powerful ingredient, and some people don't take to it very well. As a matter of fact, if you haven't used this spice before just remember: A little goes a long way. As a matter of fact, if you want, just leave it out.
  11. Stir in Worcestershire sauce, and one cup of boiling water. Reduce heat and simmer until mixture thickens, about 5 minutes. Season with salt and pepper as mixture is cooking.

    Note: whenever working with water, stocks and broths, you should never add a cold liquid to a hot mixture. The abrupt change in temperature; especially when working with meat dishes (proteins) can change the structure and taste of the finished dish... Remember to add it hot.

    Note: One of my instructors at the CIA said to aways season with salt during the cooking process. Salt, and taste, she would always say. If you salt as you cook, the dish will taste seasoned... If you add the salt at the end, it will just taste salty.
  12. Transfer the mixture to a 9-inch square baking dish, or an 8-inch round pie dish.

    Spread the mashed potato/carrot mixture over the top.

    Note: If you have a pastry spatula, you can use it to spread the potato/carrot mixture over the top, and at the same time create some fancy swirl patterns.
  13. Bake in a preheated 450f (230c), until the juices are bubbling and topping is golden brown in spots, about 20 minutes.

    Let rest, uncovered, for 5 minutes before serving to your hungry guests.

    Note: As I learned in cooking school, presentation is important... The dish that I photographed this cottage pie in is an Emil Henry fluted pie dish. In this case it's a rustic, comfort food, served in a cool-looking pie plate... We eat first with our eyes.
  14. Presentation:

    On a cold Autumn evening, this dish is sure to warm the hearts and souls of your family and guests. I like using white serving bowls; to emphasize the colors of this hearty dish (we eat first with our eyes).

    This dish, as described, is a dish that should be served family style... Nothing fancy here. Place it on the sideboard with a good crusty loaf of French bread (homemade, if you have the time), and a slab of good homemade sweet butter (butter is easy to make).

    A nice bowl of salad greens, and some dressing wouldn't be amiss. And, if this is an adult party, how about a nice bottle of wine... Red, white, or blush, your choice.

    Serve it in front of a roaring fire, and watch your guests go back for more... just make sure you have enough.

    Enjoy... Keep the faith, and keep cooking.

Printable Recipe Card

About Cottage Pie with a Twist

Course/Dish: Beef Pork Savory Pies
Main Ingredient: Beef
Regional Style: American

Show 30 Comments & Reviews

18 Dessert Recipes To Make Easter a Little Sweeter

18 Dessert Recipes To Make Easter a Little Sweeter

In some households, the holiday meal is the highlight of the day. But in others, the dessert table is the real star. If that’s the case in your house, you’re in luck. We’re sharing an assortment of recipes so there is something for everyone. Carrot cake a must-have? You’ll find an addictive one, plus a […]

12 Lovely Coffee Cake Recipes

12 Lovely Coffee Cake Recipes

Perfect with your morning coffee or as a treat after dinner, coffee cakes are one of our favorite indulgences. Sweet, heavenly, and full of flavor, coffee cakes are a great go-to for family get-togethers or a random Sunday. Grab a slice and get ready to enjoy!

Simple Glazed Ham Recipes

Simple Glazed Ham Recipes

Know how to up your baked ham game during the holidays? Glaze it! Glazes are made with simple ingredients and they add tons of flavor to baked ham. Just whisk a few ingredients together and baste the ham with it while it bakes. The glaze caramelizes on the ham and infuses its flavor into the […]