Grilled Cheese Pizza Supreme

Cara J Mastrangello


Grilled cheese and pizza are my favorite foods, so why not make the ultimate food? Adjust the "pizza toppings" to your individual taste and be amazed! haha

Blue Ribbon Recipe

What a great idea for grilled cheese! We made two just like Cara wrote the recipe and they were great. The different cheeses and fresh basil are a very nice touch. All the great flavors of a pizza in a sandwich. Love! Test Kitchen Avatar The Test Kitchen


★★★★★ 2 votes

5 Min
5 Min
Pan Fry


  • 4 slice
    bread, I like sourdough or a crust french bread for these.
  • 2-3 slice
    mozzarella cheese
  • 2-3 slice
    provolone cheese
  • a few dash(es)
    grated Parmesan cheese
  • a few Tbsp
    pizza sauce
  • 8-10 slice
  • 3-4 slice
    thin-cut ham/prosciutto
  • few Tbsp
    chopped onions
  • few Tbsp
    chopped peppers
  • few Tbsp
    sliced black olives
  • 2-3
    sliced mushrooms
  • a few
    chopped/torn basil leaves
  • ·
    butter/cooking spray

How to Make Grilled Cheese Pizza Supreme


  1. Prepare your ingredients and heat your sandwich press. Butter/lightly spray one side of each bread.
  2. On the non-buttered side, start your layers:
    1 slice mozzarella cheese
    a few teaspoons of pizza sauce
    4-5 slices pepperoni
    1-2 thin ham slices
    sprinkle of veggies you choose
    sprinkle of fresh torn/chopped basil
    1 slice of provolone cheese
  3. Top with a final slice of bread, butter side out. Carefully close sandwich press and cook a few minutes until golden brown and cheese is completely melted.
  4. Because it gets messy sometimes with the pizza sauce, I have started heating it separately in the microwave while the sandwich cooks and just using it to dip the sandwich in.

Printable Recipe Card

About Grilled Cheese Pizza Supreme

Course/Dish: Other Main Dishes Pizza
Main Ingredient: Bread
Regional Style: Italian

Show 8 Comments & Reviews

Quinoa Recipes You Need to Make ASAP

Quinoa Recipes You Need to Make ASAP

Not only is quinoa healthy, gluten-free, and high in protein, but it’s a plant food that is actually delicious! A perfect substitute for pasta or rice, quinoa should be a welcome addition to your diet. Don’t believe us? Check out these 21 delicious quinoa recipes that will have you running to the nearest grocery store […]

17 Sweet and Savory Butternut Squash Recipes

17 Sweet and Savory Butternut Squash Recipes

All hail fall’s favorite veggie – butternut squash! Well, technically it’s a fruit because of its seeds but most treat it a vegetable. Come cooler weather this sweet and nutty winter squash first makes an appearance on our produce shelves. Super versatile, butternut squash can be stuffed for a main meal, incorporated into a quick […]

Recipes You Can Make With Orange Juice

Recipes You Can Make With Orange Juice

Did you stock up when orange juice was on sale and realize you bought too much? Or, did someone put the container back in the fridge with only a little bit left? Well, OJ isn’t just for drinking with breakfast. It’s a fantastic ingredient for cooking and baking, too. Here are 12 recipes to try […]