Sandwich Shop Famous Meatballs

Martha Price


I haven't tried these yet,but I'm going to post it because it has an interesting story. In the 1960's there was a well-known sandwich shop in New York. Their meatball sandwiches were legendary,however the owner retired in 1967,and the shop closed. The owner continued to make the meatballs for family until she passed away, refusing to give anyone the recipe. Years later,the hand written recipe was found hidden at the bottom of her hope chest, along with a note saying "You finally found it!". Don't know if the story is true or if the meatballs live up to their reputation - but we'll see!


★★★★★ 1 vote

16 meatballs; 2 qts sauce
15 Min
1 Hr
Stove Top


  • 1 and 1/2 lb
    ground beef
  • 1 c
    italian seasoned dry bread crumbs
  • 3/4 c
    freshly grated romano cheese
  • 2
  • 4 clove
    garlic, minced
  • 1 Tbsp
  • 1/4 plus 1 c
    chopped fresh basil
  • 2 Tbsp
    olive oil
  • 1 can(s)
    (6 oz) tomato paste
  • 2 can(s)
    (28 oz each) crushed tomatoes
  • 1/2 tsp

How to Make Sandwich Shop Famous Meatballs


  1. Combine ground beef, bread crumbs, Romano cheese, eggs, 2 of the minced garlic cloves, milk and 1/4 cup chopped basil. Shape into 16 meatballs.
  2. In non-stick skillet heat 1 tablespoon oil over medium heat. Add half of meatballs; cook, turning once, until browned, about 3 minutes each side. Just brown them, they will finish cooking in the sauce. Remove from pan; repeat with remaining oil and meatballs.
  3. To skillet add garlic. Saute until lightly browned, about 1 minute. Stir in tomato paste. Fill paste can halfway with water; stir into mixture.
  4. In pot over medium heat combine crushed tomatoes and paste mixture. Stir in sugar and the remaining 1/3 cup of basil. Bring to a simmer; add meatballs. Partially cover; cook until meatballs are no longer pink inside, about 45 minutes. Serve with spaghetti or as a meatball sandwich on crusty bread. Hope you enjoy!

Printable Recipe Card

About Sandwich Shop Famous Meatballs

Course/Dish: Beef Sandwiches
Main Ingredient: Beef
Regional Style: Italian
Other Tag: For Kids
Hashtags: #sandwich #speghetti

Show 11 Comments & Reviews

Recipes For A Christmas Dinner

Recipes for a Christmas Dinner

Kitchen Crew

Hosting your first Christmas dinner and in need of recipes? Hosting your 20th Christmas and looking for new menu ideas? I've got you covered. These Blue Ribbon recipes will be...

How To Make Compound Butter

How to Make Compound Butter

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Compound butter sounds extremely fancy and hard to make. In reality, it is extremely simple to prepare and will enhance any meal. They are made by mixing softened butter with...

20 Recipes For A Flavorful Sunday Supper

20 Recipes for a Flavorful Sunday Supper

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Whether you're feeding your family or having a group of friends over for a casual dinner, there's nothing better than gathering around the table for a flavorful Sunday supper. You...