Classic Delmonico Steak (with Herbed Butter)

Vickie Parks


Delmonico steak is world-famous, first introduced by Delmonico's Restaurant in New York City in the mid-1800s. Over the years, Delmonico has applied to 8 different cuts of beef, though it's generally accepted to refer to a top grade of beef (such as rib-eye, New York or sirloin steak). This recipe is a classic method of preparing a quality Delmonico steak by slowly pan-searing the beef until it's sizzling hot, and then topping it with a pat of garlic-herb butter for added flavor.

Try to buy grass-fed beef. Grass-fed steak is leaner and has about 100 fewer calories than a grain-fed steak.


★★★★★ 6 votes

1 Hr 15 Min
20 Min
Pan Fry


Add to Grocery List


grass-fed steaks, 1-inch thick (new york strip, rib-eye or sirloin)
1/2 tsp
black pepper
1 tsp
sea salt
olive oil


1/2 c
unsalted butter, room temperature
2 clove
garlic, finely minced
1 tsp
lemon juice
2 tsp
fresh parsley, finely chopped

How to Make Classic Delmonico Steak (with Herbed Butter)


  • 1HERBED BUTTER: In a small bowl, combine the butter, garlic, lemon juice and parsley, and mix thoroughly. Form butter into a log shape and wrap in a sheet of waxed paper, and chill the herbed butter for at least an hour to allow the flavors to combine. (You can keep the butter chilled and slice off pieces as needed.)
  • 2STEAKS: Sprinkle the steaks with the salt and pepper, then rub each steak with a small amount of olive oil
  • 3Preheat a cast-iron skillet over medium heat. Once it's heated, turn the heat to low. Sear the steaks 3-5 minutes each side.
  • 4Reduce the heat as low as it will go, and slowly cook until the steak reaches desired internal temperature
  • 5Remove the steak from the skillet and allow it to rest 10 minutes.
  • 6While the steaks are resting, slice off two pieces of the herbed butter, and let one slice of herbed butter slowly melt on top of each steak. Serve hot.

Printable Recipe Card

About Classic Delmonico Steak (with Herbed Butter)

Course/Dish: Beef, Steaks and Chops
Main Ingredient: Beef
Regional Style: American

Show 10 Comments & Reviews

22 A+ Back-to-school Recipes

22 A+ Back-To-School Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

It's time to go back, back, back to school again! Check out these quick and easy dinner recipes that the entire family (yes, we said entire family...even the picky eaters)...