Peanut Butter Pie

Christine Schnepp


There is a tiny little gem here in Sarasota, FL. called Yoders (as seen on Man vs Food). The restaurant is set in a little Omish community and the food is incredible. If you are ever in the area you MUST stop in and have a bite. Until then, here is a copy cat recipe for their famous pie. It is heaven in your mouth!!!


★★★★☆ 3 votes



Add to Grocery List


  • ·
    1 cup powdered sugar
  • ·
    1/2 cup crunchy peanut butter
  • ·
    2 tsp cocoa powder

  • ·
    1 cup cold milk
  • ·
    1/2 cup cornstarch
  • ·
    1 tsp salt
  • ·
    1 tsp vanilla
  • ·
    3 egg yolks
  • ·
    3 cups milk
  • ·
    3 tsp butter/margerine
  • ·
    3/4 cup sugar
  • PIE

  • ·
    9 inch prepared pie crust; baked
  • ·
    3 cups whipped cream

How to Make Peanut Butter Pie


  1. To make pudding:

    Mix corn starch, salt, 1 cup milk, egg yolks and vanilla with a wire wisk and set aside.

    Heat 3 cups milk, butter and sugar until scalding, stirring constantly. Add cornstarch mixture to hot milk while stirring with whisk. Cook until thickened. Remove from heat before boiling.

    Place pudding in refrigerator to chill. Stir every 10 minutes.
  2. To make crumbs:

    Mix powdered sugar, cocoa, and peanut butter until small crumbs form (with mixer).
  3. Place 1/2 crumbs into pie shell. Spoon pudding onto crumbs. Place remaining crumbs on top of pudding, reserving a little for the topping. Top with whipped cream.

Printable Recipe Card

About Peanut Butter Pie

Course/Dish: Pies
Hashtags: #peanut, #butter

Show 11 Comments & Reviews

History Of Pie Recipe

History of Pie

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

When we think of pie we automatically think apple, pumpkin and pecan pies - but it took centuries for us to experience the pie we know today. People didn’t even...

20 Yummy Ways To Celebrate Pi Day! Recipe

20 Yummy Ways to Celebrate Pi Day!

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

How else would you celebrate Pi Day than with a nice slice of pie?!

Magic Crust Custard Pie Recipe

Magic Crust Custard Pie

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Easy custard pie recipe that is made in the blender and magically creates a crust! Click here for the Magic Crust Custard Pie recipe!