Peanut Butter Custard Pie



This is not an overly sweet pie. It is custardy and the crust is a cookie crust. We use to have a resturant near my home that use to have the best peanut butter custard pie. They used a regular pie crust but I like the added peanut butter and that little bit of sweetness in the crust. The custard is nice and thick without using a cheese product. My aunt always calls it a man's pie because it is not overly sweet.
I just like the rich peanut butter custard and the sweetness from the crust.


★★★★★ 2 votes

20 Min
35 Min



  • 1 pkg
    peanut butter cookie mix
  • 1
  • 1/2 stick

  • 5 large
    eggs whites for meringue
  • 1 1/4 c
    whole milk
  • 1 c
    baileys french vanilla coffee creamer
  • 1/2 c
    granulated sugar
  • 1 tsp
  • 3 Tbsp
    corn starch
  • 3/4 c
    peanut butter

  • 5
    egg whites
  • 1 pinch
    cream of tarter
  • 2 Tbsp

How to Make Peanut Butter Custard Pie


  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  2. Mix together the peanut butter cookie mixture with the egg and butter. Then take a pie pan and pat the cookie mixture into form a crust. Bake for about 8 to 10 minutes
  3. Mix the milk and the Bailey French Vanilla together in a bowl. Take the sugar and the butter and mix together in a sauce pan and add 1/2 of the milk mixture. Heat until warm, BUT DO NOT BOIL.
  4. Separate your eggs putting the yolks in one bowl and the egg whites in a metal or glass dish.
  5. In the bowl with the remaining milk mixture, add yolks and then stir in cornstarch. Add to warm milk mixture. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until it gets thick
  6. Remove from heat and stir in the peanut butter until it is a very smooth consistancy. Pour into cookie pie shell.
  7. In a glass or metal bowl place egg whites and cream of tartar. A stand mixer is best to use with the whisk paddle attachment but you can use a hand mixer. Beat egg whites until soft peaks form and then gradually add sugar and continue beating until stiff peaks form, approximately 1 to 2 minutes. Top the peanut butter pie.
  8. Bake for 25 to 30 minutes.

Printable Recipe Card

About Peanut Butter Custard Pie

Course/Dish: Pies
Main Ingredient: Nuts
Regional Style: American

Show 10 Comments & Reviews

8 Make at Home Stir-Fry Recipes

8 Make at Home Stir-Fry Recipes

Have a craving for stir-fry but don’t want to grab take out? Well, we’ve found 8 stir-fry recipes you can make at home. Stir-fry recipes can typically be prepared quickly which is ideal if you’re looking for a last-minute meal. From chicken to beef and veggie, these restaurant-quality recipes are loaded with flavor and delicious […]

27 Stuffed Food Recipes

27 Stuffed Food Recipes

From appetizers to meat and baked treats, stuffed recipes are fun. Stuffed peppers are always a winner but other dishes can be stuffed too. Crescent dough can be stuffed with pretty much anything. Turn a basic chicken breast into something special by stuffing it with cheese and bacon. Stuffed shells are traditionally Italian but give […]

20 Super Tasty Chicken Recipes

20 Super Tasty Chicken Recipes

“What’s for dinner?” That’s the infamous question we get tired of hearing and figuring out. But, we have your answer – chicken. Now, wait. Before you say that’s boring, trust us. We guarantee your family will love all of these 20 super tasty chicken recipes. From BBQ chicken pizzas to orange chicken and rice to Parmesan […]