Old Steak House Peanut Butter Meringue Pie

Dee Caines


I created this recipe from my memory of the best Peanut Butter Pie ever from the Steak House Restaurant in Catlettsburg, Ky. I've tried many Peanut Butter Pie recipes but love this best of all. My children and grandchildren can't wait for the holidays for this treat! It's creamy and taste tantalizing, with a little texture form the peanut butter crumble. The layering creates several different taste sensations with each bite.


★★★★★ 4 votes

1 Hr


How to Make Old Steak House Peanut Butter Meringue Pie


  1. Prepare single pie crust, place in pie dish or pan, prick crust with fork and lightly brown in 350 degree oven. Set on wire pie rack to cool.
  2. Prepare Vanilla Pudding, either boxed or from scratch, as you prefer, according to directions. Set aside to cool.
    In separate bowl, use a fork to mix 1/2 cup of creamy peanut butter with 1 cup of confectioner sugar to make a chunky crumble.
    Sprinkle crumble over bottom of pie shell, reserving abt. 4 TBSP.
    Pour completely cooled pudding over this layer and sprinkle top of pudding with 2 TBSP. of the crumble, reserving finer crumble for topping.
    Top pudding with your favorite meringue or with a whipped cream topping and sprinkle remaining crumble over topping. Lightly toast meringue under oven broiler.
    Cool in refrigerator for at least two hours before serving.

Printable Recipe Card

About Old Steak House Peanut Butter Meringue Pie

Course/Dish: Pies
Other Tag: Quick & Easy

Show 8 Comments & Reviews

31 Reasons Why There's Always Room For Dessert Recipe

31 Reasons Why There's Always Room for Dessert

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

We all know that we have a second stomach. The one that magically appears just when we think we can't eat another bite and then get a glimpse at dessert....

Delicious Citrus Desserts For A Summer Treat Recipe

Delicious Citrus Desserts for a Summer Treat

Kitchen Crew

Tart and crisp a citrus dessert just screams summertime to me. I'll never pass up dessert, especially when they're packed with citrus flavor. Pucker up, because these Blue Ribbon desserts...

34 Recipes That Prove Why Pumpkin Is Everything

34 Recipes That Prove Why Pumpkin Is Everything

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Fall means it's pumpkin time! Breakfast, lunch, dinner, dessert... can there be too much pumpkin? Not in our mind since pumpkin recipes can be sweet or savory. These 34 recipes...