Old Fashion Cream Pie

Old Fashion Cream Pie Recipe

No Photo

Have you made this?

 Share your own photo!

Lena Nestler


This recipe belonged to my Grandmother, we had this pie every Christmas. It is my favorite as a child and I still make it every Christmas for all my friends, and give them out as gifts. Hope you enjoy it!

★★★★★ 1 vote
6 depends on size of piece
35 Min
35 Min


2/3 c
brown sugar
1/3 c
white sugar
2 Tbsp
2 c
half and half cream

How to Make Old Fashion Cream Pie


  • 1Mix the first 4 ingredients in a sauce pan. Bring to a boil to thicken, then pull off the heat add 1 tablespoon of vanilla. Pour into uncooked pie shell, top with a pat of butter, then sprinkle nutmeg to taste. Bake at 350 degrees for 35 minutes or until knife comes out clean. Cool. Serve with Whipped Cream on top.

Printable Recipe Card

About Old Fashion Cream Pie

Course/Dish: Pies
Hashtags: #Christmas, #favorite