Key Lime Pie /Guaranteed to cure scurvy..well, not really, but it's fun to say.

Key Lime Pie /guaranteed To Cure Scurvy..well, Not Really, But It's Fun To Say.

No Photo

Have you made this?

 Share your own photo!

C. Lipori (organic cook)


After visiting the Florida Keys & trying many different types of key lime pie I made it a quest to come up with one that I preferred. I do prefer the custard type of pies to the whipped ones. Just my preference.

The recipe can be adjusted to levels of tartness for your liking. I prefer it tart so I use 1 cup of juice.

I always try to use all organic ingredients. It is very difficult to find organic key lime juice. You can find organic key limes and squeeze them yourself. DON"T be fooled by green key lime pies! Key lime juice is yellowish NOT bright green!

Also, every kitchen should have a cream whipper! They are the easiest way to make healthy homemade whipped cream with no hydrogenated oils! I use agave syrup because it doesn't clog the whipper. You could substitute a corn syrup but they are usually GMO's unless you buy organic and I won't use GMO's in my recipes. I will NEVER use cool whip in a recipe, have you looked at the ingredients of that stuff?

I want to note there are different types of key lime juice out there, I would look for the kind that is pure lime juice. Also, regular lime juice IS NOT the same, I would never substitute. Most larger supermarkets carry the juice but if all else fails find it online. I usually use Nellie and Joe's brand.
I swear they used to have just pure juice in it but now I noticed they add some lime oil to it. It still taste's good though.

Look at the label of your condensed milk. Some brands add extras to the mix, it should be pure milk and sugar and nothing else!

Just one last note, I wouldn't call this a "quick and easy" pie since it has to cool in the fridge, but I didn't see any other choice to click on. It is easy to make though.


★★★★★ 2 votes

6-8? it's a pie it depends on how big you slice it!
20 Min
1 Hr


  • ·
  • 1 1/4 c
    graham cracker crumbs
  • 1/4 c
  • 1/3 c
    butter melted
  • ·
  • 1 can(s)
    sweetened condensed milk
  • 4
    egg yolks
  • 3/4 c
    key lime juice ( i prefer 1 cup)
  • ·
  • 1-2 pt
    heavy whipping cream
  • 1 tsp
  • 2-3 Tbsp
    light agave syrup
  • ·
    slices of lime
  • ·
  • ·
    8-9 inch pie pan
  • ·
    cream whipper or mixer
  • ·
    also, if you are pressed for time you can always use a ready-made crust.
  • ·
    if you want to make individual pies you can use tart pans or purchase the small pie tart crusts instead. usually 2 packages will suffice.

How to Make Key Lime Pie /Guaranteed to cure scurvy..well, not really, but it's fun to say.


  1. Preheat oven to 350º. Mix crumbs , sugar, and butter throughly. Using back of spoon, press firmly onto sides and bottoms of pie pan. Bake in preheated oven for about 10 minutes. Let cool.
  2. In large bowl, add can of condensed milk, egg yolks, and Key lime juice. Mix with whisk thoroughly. Let sit a minute so any bubbles from whisking may rise to top.
  3. Pour into pie shell and bake in 400º oven for ten minutes. (You may want to cover edges of shell so it doesn't burn) Take out, cool and put into fridge until cool.
  4. In cream whipper pour whipping cream, vanilla, and agave syrup. Mix up. If you do not have a cream whipper(why not??!) you can whip your own cream in a mixer. I usually put my bowls & beaters in the freezer if I am going to whip up cold stuff.
  5. Serve pie with garnish and whipping cream. Enjoy!

Printable Recipe Card

About Key Lime Pie /Guaranteed to cure scurvy..well, not really, but it's fun to say.

Course/Dish: Pies
Other Tag: Quick & Easy
Hashtags: #lime #key

Show 3 Comments & Reviews

18 Recipes for Roasted Fall Vegetables

18 Recipes for Roasted Fall Vegetables

Brussels sprouts and potatoes and butternut squash – oh my! These roasted vegetable recipes are everything you need for the perfect fall side dish. Easy, healthy and flavorful, you’ll use produce that’s in season to make these tasty dishes. From garlic to balsamic to apples, the tasty additions to these roasted fall vegetables are winners!

Five Ways to Cook Potatoes

Five Ways to Cook Potatoes

Potatoes are a popular side dish in my house because they’re inexpensive and can be made in a variety of ways. A baked potato with butter, sour cream, and a bit of bacon makes my mouth water. Did you know there are thousands of varieties of potatoes? But, not all are equal and there are […]

10 Moist & Flavorful Pumpkin Bread Recipes

10 Moist & Flavorful Pumpkin Bread Recipes

Filled with spices of the season, pumpkin bread is a fall favorite. It can be enjoyed for breakfast, an afternoon snack, or dessert. A simple pumpkin bread recipe is delicious but many ingredients can be added to turn this quick bread into something special. Dates, cranberries, or chocolate chunks can be folded into the batter. […]