Finger Pie...GreatGrandMothers

Straws Kitchen(*o *)


My Great Grandparents, on my Mother's side of the family, were Dutch-German

My GreatGrandmother made the ''Finger Pie' and handed down her recipe and the way she made it down to my Grandmother, from her to my Mother, and then to ME.

It was always a favorite family pie, and is still one of my favorites.

I stir the flour and sugar together first in a bowl to get even distribution, they didn't.

(photos by: CinStraw)


★★★★★ 3 votes

6 to 8
10 Min
50 Min



  • 3 Tbsp
  • 1 1/2 c
    granulated sugar (i now use splenda)
  • 1 1/2 c
    heavy cream, room temperature
  • 1 tsp
    pure vanilla
  • ·
    nutmeg, to sprinkle on top

How to Make Finger Pie...GreatGrandMothers


  1. Place flour and sugar in the unbaked pie crust, then add the vanilla & cream into pie crust.

    Mix ingredients together well using your fingers. Slowly mix the dry and the liquid, being careful you don't tear the pastry.

    Sprinkle top of the filling with nutmeg, and place in the center of the oven.

    Bake 10 minutes at the 425°F, then reduce heat to 325°F and continue baking for
    approximately 45 to 55 minutes.

    Center will appear soft, but pie will set up as it cools, (Do Not Overbake).

    To get the pie to set faster you can refrigerate it.

    My mother’s recipe, handed down to her Mother, was from her Mother-in-Law, who descended from a pioneer Quaker family, uses the dry method and uses the finger for stirring.

    My mother told me that finger stirring in the unbaked crust is necessary so as not to whip the cream before baking.
    We sprinkle fresh grated nutmeg over the top before baking.
    Our family recipe, by the way, does not include any butter or eggs.

Printable Recipe Card

About Finger Pie...GreatGrandMothers

Course/Dish: Pies
Main Ingredient: Dairy
Regional Style: German
Other Tags: Quick & Easy Healthy

Show 57 Comments & Reviews

20 Dinner Ideas for When You Don’t Know What to Make

20 Dinner Ideas for When You Don’t Know What to Make

Ever feel like your weekly menu is stuck in a rut? We’re here to help. These family tested and approved recipes will shake up your kitchen and be a hit at your dinner table. Easy to make and oh-so-yummy, check out these tried and true dinner ideas for when you don’t know what to make!

18 Recipes for Roasted Fall Vegetables

18 Recipes for Roasted Fall Vegetables

Brussels sprouts and potatoes and butternut squash – oh my! These roasted vegetable recipes are everything you need for the perfect fall side dish. Easy, healthy and flavorful, you’ll use produce that’s in season to make these tasty dishes. From garlic to balsamic to apples, the tasty additions to these roasted fall vegetables are winners!

15 Chicken Recipes Big on Buffalo Flavor

15 Chicken Recipes Big on Buffalo Flavor

Buffalo wings are a necessity on game day. But this spicy, tangy, and buttery sauce can be used on more than just wings. It can transform bland chicken into something very flavorful. And how to use that Buffalo chicken? From pasta to soup and egg rolls to chicken rolls, you can use it in many […]