Easy Custard Pie

Sandy Young


When we married, in December 1961, I still hadn't met his parents. In August 1962, we went to Fall City, WA, so that I could really connect with his folks. I watched eagerly as Grandma made delicious meals with little effort. One of the desserts that she prepared was custard pie. I asked her to teach me how to make one, but she assured me that I probably wouldn't be successful. Oh, dear, Grandma! Don't ever tell Sandy that she can't do something. I found this recipe and have been making yummy custard pies ever since! (Betty Crocker's Good and Easy Cookbook)

Photo: tasteofhome.com


★★★★★ 1 vote

20 Min


  • 1
    9-in. unbaked pie crust
  • 4
    eggs, slightly beaten
  • 1/2 c
    granulated sugar
  • 1/4 tsp
  • 1 tsp
    vanilla extract
  • 2 1/2 c
    scalded milk
  • ·
    nutmeg to sprinkle on top of pie

How to Make Easy Custard Pie


  1. Heat oven to 450. If your oven tends to run a bit hot, cover the edges of the pie crust with strips of foil.
  2. Thoroughly mix eggs, sugar, salt, and vanilla.
  3. Gradually add scalded milk; pour immediately into unbaked pie shell. (To avoid spills, fill at the oven. I always put foil underneath the pie just in case any filling boils over. Burned milk is a mess to clean up, and it smells awful!)
  4. Sprinkle top with as much nutmeg as you want. We like a lot!
  5. Bake about 20 minutes or until a table knife inserted 1" from the side of filling comes out clean. The filling may look a little bit soft, but it will set later.
  6. This pie is best served slightly warm with either Cool Whip or whipped cream on top; however, we love it cold with toppings, too.

Printable Recipe Card

About Easy Custard Pie

Course/Dish: Pies

Show 4 Comments & Reviews

18 Snacks To Make Dad

18 Snacks To Make Dad

If you don’t have access to a grill to host a Father’s Day cookout, you can still show dad how much you care. How? By preparing a smorgasbord of snacks catered to dad. Does Dad enjoy eating meat? How about sausage stuffed crescent rolls or skillet chicken nachos? Dad the king of cheesy jokes? Enjoy […]

21 Easy Grilling Recipes

21 Easy Grilling Recipes

Father’s Day is just around the corner. Are you looking to do something special for dad this year? Why not take over the grilling duty and prepare an outstanding meal. From the main course to dessert, any of these 21 easy grilling recipes will make a dynamite dinner for dad.

20 Portobello Mushroom Recipes

20 Portobello Mushroom Recipes

The portobello mushroom is one of the most popular varieties of mushrooms in the world. Known as natural cancer-fighters and providing numerous health benefits, so portobellos are a tasty addition to your diet. Whether you are going low-carb, want to partake in Meatless Monday, or are on a plant-based diet, portobellos will become a staple […]