Chicken Pot Pie - PA Dutch Style

Michelle Koletar/Mertz


There are so many PA Dutch recipes, but I think Chicken Pot Pie (Bot Boi) would be at the top of the list for yumminess & popularity. This is how I make mine. I no longer make my own pot pie dough noodles, simply because my kitchen is so small. If you can't find pot pie noodles & don't want to make your own, you certainly could use large noodles in their place.
Most people boil the chicken, which is just fine, but I really love the roaster flavor & broth better. This dish also is great using turkey after the holidays!


★★★★★ 1 vote

15 Min
3 Hr


  • 1
    roaster chicken
  • 5
    yukon gold potatoes (i don't peel them)
  • 1
  • 2
    celery stalks
  • 2-3
    bouillon cubes
  • 1
    container chicken base (i use knorr's homestyle stock)
  • 12-16 oz
    pot pie noodles
  • 3
    pinches of saffron threads
  • ·
    salt & pepper
  • 1
    bunch fresh curly parsley
  • 1
    can cream of chicken soup (optional)
  • 1
    pinch nutmeg

How to Make Chicken Pot Pie - PA Dutch Style


  1. I roast my chicken the day or night before with onion & celery stalks & about 1 cup of water, then I keep adding more water. Then, I refrigerate the broth & chicken separately until next day. Remove the broth & skim any fat off the top.
  2. In a large stockpot, add the broth & fill the pot up with water until it's a little over half-way full. Add 2 bouillon cubes, some salt & pepper, pinch of nutmeg, & saffron pinches. I put the onion back in to the broth to continue adding flavor, too. Add the chicken base or stock and heat this over medium for about an hour.
  3. Add the can of cream of chicken soup (this is not pure PA Dutch, but my friend did this one time & it made the broth amazing, so now I always do). Heat some more & then taste the broth. I will add more water or more bouillon, or pepper, as I see the need. I don't add more salt until the very end if it needs, as it normally does not.
  4. Discard the onion. Add the potatoes & carrots. Keep cooking over medium heat for about another hour. Get your chicken ready by removing skin & pulling meat off the bone. I use all the dark meat & one breast & save the other breast for later. When the carrots & taters are getting fork tender, add the chicken. Get this to a low boil now.
  5. When boiling, add the pot pie noodles. Cook on boiling with lid on for about 10-15 minutes. Stir in chopped parsley. Then turn off heat & just leave the lid on until you're ready to dig in! Use a fork or a spoon or both & make sure you drink that yummy broth leftover in your bowl. Enjoy!!!
  6. If you want to make your own pot pie noodles, there are recipes all over the web. This is one from an old PA Dutch cookbook: 1 1/4 cups of flour; 1 egg shell of broth or water; 1/2 tsp. of baking powder; 1 egg; pinch of salt. Mix the dry ingredients. Then add egg & water (or broth). Roll this out & cut into squares. Drop into boiling broth for 20 minutes.

Printable Recipe Card

About Chicken Pot Pie - PA Dutch Style

Course/Dish: Chicken, Savory Pies
Other Tag: For Kids

Show 18 Comments & Reviews

Simple, Delicious, And Healthy Baked Chicken Breast Recipe

Simple, Delicious, and Healthy Baked Chicken Breast Recipe

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Boneless skinless chicken breasts are famous for being a versatile and healthy dinner recipe. They can accompany almost any side dish and, when chopped, they’re delicious on a salad. But,...

9 Healthy Chicken Crock Pot Recipes

9 Healthy Chicken Crock Pot Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Want to put an easy, flavorful and healthy chicken dinner on the table? Then try one of these 9 healthy chicken Crock Pot recipes. Cooking healthy shouldn't mean slaving away...

Chicken Breast Recipes You Need In Your Menu Rotation

Chicken Breast Recipes You Need in Your Menu Rotation

Kitchen Crew

Low in fat and high in protein, chicken breasts are a healthy and easy dinner option. If not cooked properly, though, they can be dry and not something the family...