Amish No Bake Cream pie (with 4 variations)

Amish No Bake Cream Pie (with 4 Variations) Recipe

No Photo

Have you made this?

 Share your own photo!

Stormy Stewart


The Amish make this dreamy pie but I have taken it over the top with 4 variations

★★★★★ 2 votes
1 pie


2 1/4 c
3/4 c
1/4 c
brown sugar, firmly packed
1/4 c
1/4 tsp
1 tsp
1/4 c
butter (1/2 of a stick)

How to Make Amish No Bake Cream pie (with 4 variations)


  • 1use the 1/4 cup milk to mix the cornstarch in to make thickening.
  • 2cook together all but the vanilla until it thickens add the vanilla stir well and pour into a hot baked crust. Sprinkle with nut meg. Cool and serve
  • 3Variation 1

    Add banana extract instead of vanilla, 2 drops yellow food coloring, and add sliced banana's layered on bottom of crust and pour 1/2 the filling, add another layer of bananas and pour the remainder of the filling over top.
  • 4variation 2

    add 1 cup chocolate chips to the pan when it is half way thickened and make it a chocolate cream pie.
  • 5variation 3

    same as above but add chocolate mint chips for chocolate mint cream pie
  • 6Variation 4

    add 3/4 cup peanut butter just before you pour it into the crust, mixing until all mixed

Printable Recipe Card

About Amish No Bake Cream pie (with 4 variations)

Course/Dish: Pies