Homemade Butterfinger Ice Cream

Homemade Butterfinger Ice Cream Recipe

No Photo

Have you made this?

 Share your own photo!

Sheri Mullins


This recipe came from my mother-in-law who made vanilla ice cream this way for many years. My husband loves butterfingers so in our ice cream maker he decided to add crushed up butterfingers. The kids won't let him make it any other way now! We make this in a 5-gallon electric ice cream maker.

NOTE: This recipe does use raw eggs.


★★★★★ 1 vote

5 quart freezer
30 Min
1 Hr 30 Min


Add to Grocery List

16 oz
half and half
16 oz
whipping cream
1 1/2 Tbsp
vanilla extract
3 c
dash of salft
regular size butterfingers, crushed
whole milk - to finish filling ice cream freezer
rock salt

How to Make Homemade Butterfinger Ice Cream


  • 1Rinse metal freezer container to get it wet and place in freezer.
  • 2In large mixing bowl, beat eggs until fluffy.
  • 3Add vanilla, sugar and salt; mix well.
  • 4Mix in half and half and whipping cream; mix well.
  • 5Place bowl with mixture into refrigerator to get cold for 30 minutes.
  • 6Crush up butterfingers with rolling pin.
  • 7Pour cold mixture into cold metal container bucket (with insert).
  • 8Add crushed butterfingers.
  • 9Add enough whole milk to fill line on container.
  • 10Cover with lid and attach to electric ice cream bucket.
  • 11Pour in ice, water and rock salt. Start ice cream maker and continue supplementing with ice and rock salt until ice cream is finished.
  • 12NOTE: To make Srawberry Ice Cream
    Mash 5 cups fresh strawberries in small bowl. Do steps 1 thru 4. Add strawberries to mixture; place bowl in refrigerator to get cold about 30 min. Pour cold mixture into metal container. Do steps 9 thru 11.
  • 13NOTE: to make Chocolate Ice Cream
    6 eggs, 2 cups sugar, 1 cup cocoa powder, 1-1/2 cup chocolate syrup, 16 oz. half and half, 16 oz. whipping cream, 2 t. Vanilla
    Do steps 1 thru 5; pour cold mixture into metal container. Do steps 9 thru 11

Printable Recipe Card

About Homemade Butterfinger Ice Cream

Course/Dish: Ice Cream & Ices

Show 2 Comments & Reviews

The Great Banana Split Debate Recipe

The Great Banana Split Debate

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Walk into any old fashioned soda shop or look at the menu at your favorite ice cream store and you’ll most likely see a banana split on the menu. It’s...

The Ice Cream Cone: Great Minds Think Alike Recipe

The Ice Cream Cone: Great Minds Think Alike

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

An ice cream cone is a cylindrical object resembling an upside-down triangle that is hollow in the center. Placing a scoop of ice cream on top of it makes ice...