Amish Custard Pie

Cassie *


I was given this recipe from an old Amish neighbor...she always shared her yummy recipes with me, and I was always glad to receive them...enjoy!


☆☆☆☆☆ 0 votes

1 - 9 inch deep dish pie
10 Min
45 Min


Add to Grocery List

  • 1/3 c
    sugar - (i always add an extra 1/2 tablespoon )
  • 2 tsp
    all purpose flour
  • 3 c
  • 3
  • 1/2 tsp
  • 1/4 tsp
    vanilla extract
  • 1/4 tsp
  • 1
    unbaked pie shell i cheated and used store bought - never

How to Make Amish Custard Pie


  1. Combine sugar, flour, salt and eggs, vanilla and mix until smooth.
  2. Heat milk to boiling point. Add 1 cup hot milk to egg mixture. Pour that into the remaining hot milk.
  3. Pour into unbaked pie shell. Sprinkle pie with nutmeg. Sometimes I use cinnamon.
  4. Bake at 350 degrees F. for 45-60 minutes.

Printable Recipe Card

About Amish Custard Pie

Course/Dish: Pies
Main Ingredient: Eggs
Regional Style: American

Show 20 Comments & Reviews

Easy No-bake Desserts With Simple Ingredients Recipe

Easy No-Bake Desserts With Simple Ingredients

Kitchen Crew

Who wants to turn their oven on for long periods of time during the summer? I know I don't. Which is why I'm a huge fan of no-bake desserts. Besides...

Take A Road Trip And Never Leave The Kitchen Recipe

Take a Road Trip and Never Leave the Kitchen

Kitchen Crew

I've stayed close to home this summer. With a busy schedule, heading out of town wasn't in the cards. But I plan to take a road trip and never leave...

19 Raspberry Recipes Bursting With Flavor

19 Raspberry Recipes Bursting With Flavor

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

We're planting a little seed about what you need to make this week... Try one of these 19 yummy raspberry recipes bursting with flavor!