This recipe is private

Baseball Hat Cookie Cups

Raven Higheagle


The last time that I made cookie cups, a few of them overflowed in the mini muffin tin. When I popped them out once they were cool, I noticed that the when they were upside down, they looked like baseball hats. I decided to run with the idea. The next time, I put the dough into the pan so that the dough would form a brim. After baking, I filled the cookie cups with peanut butter cups and decorated them with blue candy melts.

These Baseball Hat Cookie Cups are perfect for parties, your kid’s sports teams or even Father’s Day. You can customize them with team colors, simple logos or initials.


☆☆☆☆☆ 0 votes

Makes 24
20 Min
15 Min


  • 16 oz
    24 count package pillsbury ready to bake sugar cookies
  • 24
    unwrapped reese's peanut butter cups
  • 1 pkg
    blue candy melts (or what ever the team color is)
  • ·
    blue sprinkles

How to Make Baseball Hat Cookie Cups


  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Grease the cups and the top surface of a mini muffin tin.
  2. Break apart the 24 sugar cookies in a package of Pillsbury Ready To Bake sugar cookies.
  3. Place one piece of the sugar cookie dough into each cup and mound the dough up on one side, so that some of the dough is sitting on top of the pan.
  4. (If these segmented cookies aren’t available in your area, use about 1 tablespoon of any sugar cookie dough in each muffin tin cup.)
  5. Bake the cookies at 350 degrees for 12-15 minutes.
  6. Remove from the oven and gently press an unwrapped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup into each cookie cup.
  7. Allow the cookies to cool completely and then carefully remove them from the pan.
  8. I used a thin knife to apply a little pressure to the outside edge of the cookie cup and they popped right out.
  9. If you want to make the cookies look even more like baseball hats, use a thin knife to cut off some of the outside edge of the cookie cup.
  10. Then, you can use your finger tips to gently mold the edges of the cookie cups by pressing the crumbly edges into a straight edge.
  11. Melt several of the blue candy melts (you want to work with a small amount at a time because it will harden after a few minutes) and pour into a sandwich baggie.
  12. Cut a tiny hole in the corner and decorate the baseball hat. Add a blue sprinkle on the top.
  13. Melt more candy melts, as necessary.

Printable Recipe Card

About Baseball Hat Cookie Cups

Course/Dish: Cookies
Main Ingredient: Flour
Regional Style: American
Other Tags: Quick & Easy, For Kids

Leave a Comment

18 Best Christmas Cookies For A Cookie Exchange Recipe

18 Best Christmas Cookies for a Cookie Exchange

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Don’t be that person who shows up to the Christmas cookie exchange with store-bought cookies. Even if you put them on a plate, people know! There’s just that special something...

Simple Christmas Cookies For A Cookie Exchange Recipe

Simple Christmas Cookies for a Cookie Exchange

Kitchen Crew

One of the highlights of the holiday season, for me, is making Christmas cookies. It reminds me of being a kid in the kitchen with my mother. Every year I...

C Is For Cookie Recipes Everyone Will Want To Eat

C is for Cookie Recipes Everyone Will Want to Eat

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Let's chat cookies. From chocolate chip to sugar and cream filled, they're a dunkable treat that can't be beat. Here are 14 cookie recipes that'll quickly become a family favorite....