Great Grandma Sabin's Sour Milk Cookies

Diane Schmidt


This recipe has been handed down through generations. When my Grandma Wilson made these cookies when I was a child she made them as she was shown, there were no measurements she would say it takes 2 handfuls or a pinch or two...LOL... took awhile to transfer her recipe into measurements but finally and thankfully it has been done. These cookies are moist and almost cake-like. (sort of like Amish sugar cookies). Also, the amount of flour you use varies. You want the dough to be not sticky but only just very. It's a very soft dough, don't over work it. It is worth the work!


★★★★★ 1 vote

10 Min


  • 2 large
  • 1 c
    shortening, crisco, not butter flavor
  • 2 c
  • 2/3 c
    sour milk
  • 1 tsp
    baking soda
  • 1/2 tsp
  • 1 tsp
    vanilla extract
  • 1 tsp
  • 4-6 c

How to Make Great Grandma Sabin's Sour Milk Cookies


  1. Beat eggs well. Add sugar and beat. Add shortening and be continue beating. Sift dry ingredients (use 4 cups flour) together and alternating with the sour milk add to egg mixture , continue beating...slowly add additional flour until dough forms a sticky ball.
  2. Turn dough out unto a floured surface. Slowly kneed in additional flour until the dough is not sticky on the outside but still a soft dough. divide in half and roll the dough out to about 1/4 inch thickness. My Grandma had this large circle cookie cutter she used to make these over sized cookies. And they do work better if you make them large. I just use a glass dipped in flour to make my cookies. You can use shaped cutters but use large ones. Once you have your cookies on the tray, sprinkle with plain white sugar. You can be festive and colored sugar but I like the more traditional white sugar.
  3. Bake about 10 minutes at 375* degrees. Bake until cookies puff up a bit and dough looks dry. Do not over cook them or they will be hard.

Printable Recipe Card

About Great Grandma Sabin's Sour Milk Cookies

Course/Dish: Cookies Other Snacks
Main Ingredient: Flour
Regional Style: American

Show 4 Comments & Reviews

14 Hearty Creamy Soup Recipes

14 Hearty Creamy Soup Recipes

What’s better than a bowl of creamy soup on a cold night? Not much in our mind. We can’t think of many better things than warming up with a big bowl of smoky potato bacon soup, thick Zuppa Toscana, or heavenly chicken tortilla soup. Maybe you want to put your slow cooker to use and […]

Five Delicious Ways to Satisfy a Cheese Craving

Five Delicious Ways to Satisfy a Cheese Craving

Is cheese a food group? Like pizza, I think it should be. In my mind, cheese makes everything better. If you agree, here are five delicious ways you can satisfy your cheesy craving. The ultimate way to eat cheese is in macaroni and cheese. Jane Kear (Edmond, OK) shared her recipe for 8 Cheese Baked […]

12 Yummy Ways to Use Bananas That’s Not in Banana Bread

12 Yummy Ways to Use Bananas That’s Not in Banana Bread

It seems no matter how hard we try, eating a bunch of bananas before they turn brown is a challenge. What happens when bananas get a little too ripe? It’s time to make banana bread. Or is it? If you want to make banana bread, check out 11 of our best banana bread recipes. But, […]