Copycat Marshmallow Peeps Recipe

Susan Cutler


I was browsing yesterday and came across this recipe for making Homemade Peeps. Since Easter is right around the corner, I felt compelled to post for everyone to see. It was shared by JJensenSC from

Homemade Peeps, I thought they might be a great idea for anyone trying to make homemade items these days to have this recipe in their Holiday go to file(s).

These are the Author’s remarks,
"Here's our favorite recipe for making the famous Marshmallow Peeps at home!"


★★★★★ 1 vote



Add to Grocery List

1 pkg
unflavored gelatin (2 1/2 teaspoons)
1/3 + 1/4 c
cold water
1 c
colored sugar (or make your own with food coloring and sugar)
cocoa powder and water (optional; for eyes and nose)

How to Make Copycat Marshmallow Peeps Recipe


  • 1Lightly coat a silicone mold or small pan with non-stick spray.

    In a small saucepan, combine 1/3 cup cold water and sugar. Whisk together over medium heat.

    Once sugar is dissolved, stop stirring and cook until mixture reaches softball stage (between 235-240°F).

    While sugar mixture is boiling, sprinkle gelatin over 1/4 C cold water in a large, deep heatproof bowl (a stand mixer bowl is perfect for this).

    Let stand for about 1 minute, until it softens.

    Once the syrup reaches softball stage, remove from heat. Turn mixer on low and carefully pour hot syrup into into gelatin, avoiding the beaters and sides of the bowl.

    Increase to medium-high speed and beat for 8-10 minutes, until mixture thickens, turns white and can hold soft peaks.

    Immediately and quickly spoon into prepared mold or pan (the mixture will set quickly so don’t wait long).

    If you used a pan, cut desired shapes out of marshmallow with lightly greased cookie cutters. If you used a mold, wait a few minutes and then pop them out of the mold.

    Drop marshmallows onto a plate covered with colored sugar and move them around to coat each side.

Printable Recipe Card

About Copycat Marshmallow Peeps Recipe

Course/Dish: Candies

Show 10 Comments & Reviews

Pinterest Pass Or Fail: Frankenstein Marshmallow Pops Recipe

Pinterest Pass or Fail: Frankenstein Marshmallow Pops

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Halloween is just around the corner and we were looking for a spooky treat for our next Pinterest Pass or Fail. We came across Kelly from's Frankenstein Marshmallow Pops...

Create Your Favorite Candy Classics At Home Recipe

Create Your Favorite Candy Classics at Home

Kitchen Crew

Happy Halloween! At my house, we always have lots of trick or treaters. I love to see the kids in their costumes and so happy when I throw candy into...

25 No-bake Dessert Recipes That Are Bringing Sexy Back

25 No-Bake Dessert Recipes That Are Bringing Sexy Back

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Not only are these no-bake desserts super easy to make, but these recipes are incredibly tempting and sure to satisfy your cravings!