Reese's Peanut Butter Cake

Kimi Gaines


This cake is a hit for anyone that is a peanut butter chocolate fan. It is a 4 layer cake with peanut butter frosting between each layer and chopped up Reese Cups on every layer, with the sides frosted with milk chocolate frosting. To top it off chopped Reese Cups all on top and garnished around the sides. This a signature cake is one that my daughter and I created. This is a time consuming cake, definitely not a quick cake to make.

★★★★★ 3 votes
15 Min
30 Min


Add to Grocery List

2 box
duncan hines classic yellow cake mix
2 pkg
small instant vanilla pudding
16 oz
container of sour cream
1 c
2/3 c
butter, melted
2 can(s)
milk chocolate frosting
1 large
bag of reese cup family size bag


1 c
creamy peanut butter
32 oz
powdered sugar, sifted (8cups)
1 c
plus 2 tablespoons milk
2 tsp
pure vanilla extract

How to Make Reese's Peanut Butter Cake


  • 1Heat oven to 350F. Grease 4-8inch cake pans generously (batter is very thick).
  • 2In a mixing bowl combine all ingredients except peanut butter cups and frosting; mix, scraping the bowl. Mix on high speed for 3 minutes. Evenly distribute cake batter (I can only put 3 pans in my oven at a time).
  • 3Bake for 25-30 minutes, checking at 25 minutes. Let cool 10 minutes and then invert onto a baking rack. Completely cool before frosting.
  • 4While cakes are cooling unwrap all candies and chop up into small pieces.
    In large mixing bowl cream peanut butter; gradually add in half the powdered sugar (I do not sift my sugar and it is smooth as silk)beating well. Add remaining sugar alternately with milk, beating until smooth enough to spread. Add in vanilla; beat well.
  • 6On bottom layer frost with peanut butter frosting, sprinkle with cut up candy. Repeat this on all layer including the top. Frost sides with chocolate frosting. Garnish bottom side of cake with remaining candy.

Printable Recipe Card

About Reese's Peanut Butter Cake

Course/Dish: Cakes, Candies, Chocolate

Show 8 Comments & Reviews

Sponge Cake Recipes That'll Inspire You To Get Baking

Sponge Cake Recipes That'll Inspire You to Get Baking

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

While the concept of a sponge cake is simple (eggs, butter, sugar, and flour), the result is a very impressive dessert. The first sponge cake recipe appeared as early as...

Flavorful Blueberry Recipes To Brighten Your Day

Flavorful Blueberry Recipes to Brighten Your Day

Kitchen Crew

The markets are bursting with blueberries these days! That makes me very happy because not only are they yummy, they're super healthy. Packed with antioxidants, research shows blueberries can help...

18 Refreshing Lemon Recipes

18 Refreshing Lemon Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

When life gives you lemons, make these delicious lemon recipes!