Old Fashioned Poppy Seed Cake

Pat Duran


This recipe was given to me by the Frankenmuth Historical Association and Mrs Zehnder from Frankenmuth ,Michigan.
This recipe has been in her family since she was a child in the 30's..It was always their Birthday Cake when she was a child and her children love it too and now her grandchildren love it!

★★★★★ 1 vote
15 Min
25 Min


Add to Grocery List


1/4 to 1/2 c
poppy seeds- more or less to your liking -i like to use 1/2 cup
3/4 c
3/4 c
butter or spry(spry is a shortening like crisco)
1 1/4 c
granulated sugar
1/4 c
brown sugar, lightly packed
2 c
all purpose flour
2 tsp
baking powder
1/2 tsp
baking soda
1 tsp
4 large
egg whites, stiffly beaten


4 large
egg yolks
2 c
1 c
granulated sugar
3 Tbsp
1 tsp
vanilla extract


1 c
solid crisco or spry shortening
1/2 tsp
vanilla extract
1/2 tsp
butter extract
3 Tbsp
powdered coffee creamer
1/4 c
warm water-more if needed
4 c
powdered sugar
coconut or nuts

How to Make Old Fashioned Poppy Seed Cake


  • 1Preheat oven to 375^. Grease two 9-inch cake pan then place a circle of waxed paper in the pans and grease the paper; set aside.
    Soak the poppy seed in the milk, the longer the soak the better;set aside.
  • 2CAKE:
    Cream the butter and sugars until light and fluffy. Then add the milk and poppy seeds. Add flour, baking powder, baking soda and vanilla.
  • 3Fold in the beaten egg whites. Pour equally into the prepared pans. Bake for 25 minutes or until tested done when tooth pick is inserted in center of cakes. Cool 2 minutes in tins; remove from pan and remove waxed paper carefully. Cool completely on wire racks. Prepare filling.
    Heat milk and sugar then add cornstarch and yolks mixed together. Cook till thick and then cool. Spread between layers. Make Frosting.
    Cream shortening in the bowl of mixer. Add the extracts. To the powdered creamer add the water and mix until dissolved and add to the shortening mixture and mix on low until the water is incorporated into the shortening. Slowly add the powdered sugar 1 cup at a time, mixing on low speed. You may need a little more water depending on consistency of icing you want. Garnish top with coconut or nuts ,if desired.
    This does not need to be refrigerated.

Printable Recipe Card

About Old Fashioned Poppy Seed Cake

Course/Dish: Cakes
Main Ingredient: Spice/Herb/Seasoning
Regional Style: Polish
Other Tag: Quick & Easy

Show 16 Comments & Reviews

Flavorful Blueberry Recipes To Brighten Your Day

Flavorful Blueberry Recipes to Brighten Your Day

Kitchen Crew

The markets are bursting with blueberries these days! That makes me very happy because not only are they yummy, they're super healthy. Packed with antioxidants, research shows blueberries can help...

Sponge Cake Recipes That'll Inspire You To Get Baking

Sponge Cake Recipes That'll Inspire You to Get Baking

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

While the concept of a sponge cake is simple (eggs, butter, sugar, and flour), the result is a very impressive dessert. The first sponge cake recipe appeared as early as...

14 Best Chocolate Cupcake Recipes

14 Best Chocolate Cupcake Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Mmm, there’s just something magical about a tasty chocolate cupcake that just makes our mouths water. We searched high and low on Pinterest for some seriously awesome chocolate cupcake recipes...