Bread and Butter Squash Pickles (Regular and Sugar-Free)

Lisa Crum


Last year we wound up with a bumper crop of yellow squash. Trying to be creative in how we put it up, I experimented with a regular cucumber pickle recipe and came up with these. Turns out, we liked them better than cucumber pickles! They're crisp and tasty on sandwiches, or on the side with a bowl of soup beans. Or, you can grind up the ingredients and make relish, which is also very good. We tried it both ways. Though the original ingredients called for sugar, I made almost all our batches with Splenda instead, after I experimented with a batch and found that they too were delicious (we do a lot of sugar-free cooking). We have a few jars left and they're still fresh-tasting and crisp every time we pop open another jar.


★★★★★ 2 votes

1 Hr
10 Min


Add to Grocery List

yellow straight or crookneck squash, thinly sliced (any size but the smaller they are, the fewer seeds)
onions, sliced into thin rings
bell peppers, thinly sliced (optional)
1/4 c
2 1/4 c
sugar or 3 1/2 cups splenda
2 1/4 c
apple cider vinegar
2 tsp
celery seed
2 tsp
mustard seed
1 Tbsp
pickling spice

How to Make Bread and Butter Squash Pickles (Regular and Sugar-Free)


  • 1Do not peel squash. Slice squash, onions, and green pepper in thin strips. Add 1/4 cup salt, cover with cold water. Let stand for one hour, use ice to keep cool or refrigerate.
  • 2Combine sugar, vinegar, celery seed and turmeric. Boil ingredients for three minutes, stirring occasionally, then add drained squash mixture. Simmer for three more minutes. Bring to a boil. Pack in hot canning jars and fill to 1/2 inch of top of jar with juice. Makes about 4 or 5 pints, double if you want more.
  • 4Notes: To a double batch I used for spices:
    3 T. mustard seed
    2 T. pickling spice
    1 T. celery seed
    And a total of 7 cups splenda to 4.5 cups vinegar

Printable Recipe Card

About Bread and Butter Squash Pickles (Regular and Sugar-Free)

Show 18 Comments & Reviews

How To Make The Best Homemade Caramel Sauce Recipe

How to Make the Best Homemade Caramel Sauce

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Caramel sauce turns an ordinary dessert into something amazing. It can be drizzled onto cheesecake, a dip for fruit, used to top an apple pie and let's not forget about...

19 Buzzworthy Tequila Recipes

19 Buzzworthy Tequila Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Want to add some zip to your cooking? Try one of these 19 buzzworthy recipes featuring tequila!