Better Than Bobby's Mushrooms (Bobby Flay)

Better Than Bobby's Mushrooms (bobby Flay) Recipe

No Photo

Have you made this?

 Share your own photo!

Erin M


Before Bobby Flay became a huge star on Food Network he had a 1/2 hour show on Lifetime that he shared with Katie Brown. One day he made stuffed mushrooms, and my husband and I played with the recipe and made we called them Better Than Bobby' Bobby Flay is a huge star, but this recipe was created before he was the big star!


★★★★★ 1 vote

15 Min
1 Hr


Add to Grocery List

  • 1 package
    mushrooms, fresh
  • 5-6 strips
    bacon cooked crisp
  • 1 cup
    soft cheese havarti is my favorite
  • 1 cup
    hard cheese such as mozzarella
  • 1/2 cup
    onions finely chopped
  • ·
    fresh garlic finely minced..about 4-5 cloves
  • ·
    butter (approx. half a stick, margarine works too)

How to Make Better Than Bobby's Mushrooms (Bobby Flay)


  1. clean mushrooms by wiping with damp kitchen towel. Remove stems and save. Place mushrooms on cookie sheet. Place small pats of butter between the mushrooms (very important step..they don't turn out quite right if you don't do this). Mix cheese, onion, garlic, and bacon.(you can also chop mushroom stems and add to mixture. Sometimes I do, sometimes I don't.) Fill mushroom caps with mixture. Place in a 375 degree oven for 45-60 minutes. The longer you cook them the better they are. These are delicious, even kids that don't like onions and garlic like these. The onions and garlic provide a wonderful flavor, but aren't over powering like it seems they would be. The mixture of cheese, onion, garlic and bacon meld together into a very delicious appetizer. You'll fight over who gets to scrape the cheese off the pan when you remove the mushrooms :-)
  2. ALSO: you can vary this recipe with whatever cheese you prefer. I recommend one soft and one hard cheese. Sometimes I use Havarti, mozzarella and some cream cheese. You can use orange cheeses, too. Whatever you prefer. I recommend doubling the batch if you have more than 3-4 people. They go quickly!

Printable Recipe Card

About Better Than Bobby's Mushrooms (Bobby Flay)

You May Also Like:

Show 9 Comments & Reviews

Tackle The Big Game With Fantastic Game Day Recipes

Tackle the Big Game with Fantastic Game Day Recipes

Kitchen Crew

It's the most magical Sunday of the year... the Super Bowl! My team's not playing (again), but that won't stop me from watching the big game. I'm having a few...

15 Chicken Wing Recipes For The Big Game

15 Chicken Wing Recipes for the Big Game

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Check out 15 chicken wing recipes that'll make you an MVP on game day. Extra napkins will be necessary.

13 Addicting Nacho Recipes

13 Addicting Nacho Recipes

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Cheesy, yummy, absolute amazingness! Needless to say, we kinda sorta really love nachos :)