Welsh Rarebit, circa 1930

Welsh Rarebit, Circa 1930

No Photo

Have you made this?

 Share your own photo!

Lynnda Cloutier


Welsh Rarebit (or Rabbit) is a tangy cheese sauce served over toast or cracker, perfect for a luncheon dish for the ladies or a snack for the gentle men. some rarebits call for beer or ale, but this one is made with milk. The only clue to the origin of this recipe is the word Proctors, which might be the name of the hostess who served it to the lady who transcribed it. source unknown


★★★★★ 1 vote


  • ·
    2 tbsp. softened butter
  • ·
    2 tbsp. flour
  • ·
    2 cups milk
  • ·
    2 tsp. dry mustard
  • ·
    3/4 tsp. salt
  • ·
    1/4 tsp. coarsely ground black pepper
  • ·
    1/8 tsp. cayenne pepper
  • ·
    3 cups grated american or cheddar cheese
  • ·
    2 eggs, beaten
  • ·
    1/4 tsp. chopped brined hot peppers, optional

How to Make Welsh Rarebit, circa 1930


  1. Melt butter in heavy 2 quart pan over low heat. Whisk flour into butter to combine. Turn heat to medium and cook mixture for 1 minute, stirring with wooden spoon to make a roux. add milk and cook, stirring constantly til sauce begins to thicken and small bubbles form around edges, 4 to 6 minutes. Don’t overcook.
  2. Add mustard, salt, pepper, cayenne pepper and cheese and stir briskly. Cook over low heat til cheese is completely melted. Remove from heat.
    Whisk about 1/4 cup of the sauce into beaten eggs to temper them. Return egg mixture to rarebit and whisk to combine. Set pan over low heat and continue cooking, whisking constantly, til eggs are cooked and rarebit is heated through, about 2 minutes. Don’t boil. Add peppers if desired. Serve Welsh Rarebit on toast or Pilot crackers, a crunchy “down east” favorite in New England.
    Note: you can substitute 1 tsp. of prepared mustard for the dry mustard. Adjust seasonings to taste.

Printable Recipe Card

About Welsh Rarebit, circa 1930

Leave a Comment

22 Zucchini Recipes That'll Make You A Cooking Rock Star

22 Zucchini Recipes That'll Make You a Cooking Rock Star

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Make the most out your summer cooking with delicious zucchini recipes. They'll make you a cooking rock star.

15 Sheet Pan Brussels Sprouts Recipes To Make Dinner Prep Easy

15 Sheet Pan Brussels Sprouts Recipes to Make Dinner Prep Easy

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

What's the easiest way to quickly prepare a healthy dinner? Make everything on a sheet pan! And what vegetable only gets tastier when roasted? Brussels sprouts! Random fact... did you...

Starting The New Year With A Healthier Menu

Starting the New Year With a Healthier Menu

Kitchen Crew

January is a great time to reset eating habits and start the year with a healthier menu. Here are some recipes that are not only healthy but delicious. They'll definitely...