Peppy Pimento Grilled Cheese

Lori Frazee


I confess, I'm a cheese monger, OK I don't deal in it, but I LOVE IT!!!! All of it! And when I think about good ol' Southern cheese, I think about Pimento Cheese. So I put my own spicy twist on it, and you guessed, to the grill I go!!! Remember, girls can grill too!!! I'm making this as a sandwich, but this peppy pimento cheese makes a great spread or appetizer dip as well

Blue Ribbon Recipe

This is a really snappy grilled cheese sandwich! I have long enjoyed grilled pimento cheese sandwiches at a local restaurant, but this one steps it up several notches. There is just enough heat in this to make you take notice but not enough to set you on fire. A great grilled sandwich. The Test Kitchen


★★★★☆ 3 votes

20 Min
15 Min


Add to Grocery List

8 oz
freshly shredded sharp cheddar cheese
8 oz
freshly shredded pepper jack cheese
4 oz
2 Tbsp
chopped jalapenos
1/4 c
crumble feta cheese
1/4 c
cottage cheese
1/4 c
2 tsp
fresh cracked black pepper
1 tsp
garlic salt
pieces multigrain bread per person
olive oil or butter for both side of bread
2 Tbsp
fire roasted salsa

How to Make Peppy Pimento Grilled Cheese


  • 1Shred your cheese
    Note: keep it cold, so work fast, so it won't gum up.
  • 2In a large bowl place all you ingredients and mix thoroughly. Except the crab.
  • 3Lightly oil or butter both sides of the bread to be grilled.
  • 4Grill one side of the bread till golden brown. Flip it over, and spread pimento mix on each of the browned side of the bread. Add your Crab at this point on top of the pimento cheese mix, you could substitute shrimp or another crab favorite
  • 5Place on grill or hot skillet, uncooked, oiled side down, until toasted to your desired doneness.
  • 6Place the two sides together, slice and serve with a fresh salad or a side of fruit. I love a light style pasta salad with this sandwich.

Printable Recipe Card

About Peppy Pimento Grilled Cheese

Main Ingredient: Dairy
Regional Style: Southern
Collection: World Food Champs

Show 23 Comments & Reviews

Simple Dip Recipes For Your Next Gathering

Simple Dip Recipes For Your Next Gathering

Kitchen Crew

From spinach and artichoke to classic onion and cheese, there's nothing better than starting an evening with friends than with a tasty dip. It's like a magical appetizer nobody can...

12 Easy To Make Cheese Balls Recipe

12 Easy to Make Cheese Balls

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

There's nothing cheesy about a cheese ball! This vintage app is making a comeback. Get the party started with crowd favorite cheese balls.

25 Game-day Recipes That'll Make You The Mvp

25 Game-Day Recipes That'll Make You the MVP

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Whether your favorite team wins or loses, everyone will be a winner after they snack on these crowd-pleasing recipes.