Dad & Mom Johnson's Creamy Peanut Butter Candy

Dad & Mom Johnson's Creamy Peanut Butter Candy Recipe

No Photo

Have you made this?

 Share your own photo!

Linda Gorby


Dad and mom Johnson's (handed down recipe circa 1936) always fixed this Peanut Butter Candy,Christmas through New Year's; (way before "RPBCups" ever existed)! So easy to yummy, and oh, so good...!


★★★★★ 1 vote

If cut 1 inch square, about 6
10 Min
20 Min


  • 2 c
  • 1/2 c
    whole milk (do not use reduced or non- fat)
  • 1 Tbsp
  • 1/2 tsp
  • 1 c
    peanut butter (creamy or chunky)
  • 1/4 c
    nuts, crushed (optional)

How to Make Dad & Mom Johnson's Creamy Peanut Butter Candy


  1. Utensils needed:
    heavy duty (cast iron best) fry pan or heavy duty stainless steel or non-stick fry pan; 8"-9" round pie or cake pan; whisk; glass measuring cup; wooden spoon; teaspoon; spatula; saran wrap; sharp knife; heavy duty pot holders.
  2. Set aside one cupful of cold water in a glass measuring cup, and a teaspoon to use for finding out "soft ball" stage. (You may want to set aside 2 cups of cold water, just in case first test is not ready yet. Do not re-use same cup of cold water you tested in first time).
  3. In heavy-duty (cast iron best) fry pan, or heavy bottomed stainless steel or non-stick fry pan, mix the following together:
  4. 2 C sugar, 1/2 C milk, 1 TBSP butter, and 1/2 TSP salt
  5. On medium-high heat, cook and stir mixture with whisk, or wooden spoon, UNTIL boiling.
  6. Continue boiling WITHOUT STIRRING, until mixture reaches "soft ball" stage. Quickly do the following:
  7. Test to find "soft ball" stage: use a teaspoon to take a pinch of boiling mixture and drop into the cup of cold water. If the mixture forms a "soft ball" while dropping to bottom of cup, it is ready. It if is NOT, re-test in 2nd cup of cold water set aside earlier.
  8. When at "soft ball" stage,quickly and carefully remove from heat. IT IS HOT!

    Immediately, using a spatula or wooden spoon, ADD the 1 C of peanut butter, stirring into mixture.
  9. Immediately, pour into prepared buttered pan (8"-9" round pie or cake pan)will do fine.
  10. At this point you can add your choice of chopped nuts, sprinkling on top.
  11. Cool in pan, then cut into 1" squares with sharp knife.
    Enjoy. Disappears fast.

    To store, cover with plastic wrap and do not refrigerate.

Printable Recipe Card

About Dad & Mom Johnson's Creamy Peanut Butter Candy

Show 2 Comments & Reviews

Give The Gift Of Food This Holiday Season Recipe

Give The Gift of Food This Holiday Season

Kitchen Crew

Whether looking to make something for the host/hostess of a holiday party or wanting to give something personal to a friend, I love the idea of making homemade treats. There's...

Pinterest Pass Or Fail: Frankenstein Marshmallow Pops Recipe

Pinterest Pass or Fail: Frankenstein Marshmallow Pops

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Halloween is just around the corner and we were looking for a spooky treat for our next Pinterest Pass or Fail. We came across Kelly from's Frankenstein Marshmallow Pops...

25 No-bake Dessert Recipes That Are Bringing Sexy Back

25 No-Bake Dessert Recipes That Are Bringing Sexy Back

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Not only are these no-bake desserts super easy to make, but these recipes are incredibly tempting and sure to satisfy your cravings!