NutterButter and Chocolate Overload Cupcakes

Recipe Rating:
 62 Ratings
Serves: 24
Prep Time:
Cook Time:
Cooking Method: Bake


1 box cake mix, devils food..mix as directed
1 pkg regular sized nutterbutter cookies
1 pkg mini nutterbutter cookies
1 can(s) chocolate frosting
1 c creamy peanut butter
8 Tbsp butter room temperature
2 c powdered sugar
3-4 Tbsp heavy can use milk also..until frosting is thinned a little
2 tsp pure vanilla

The Cook

Debbie wright Recipe
Well Seasoned
Sulphur, LA (pop. 20,410)
Member Since Sep 2010
Debbie's notes for this recipe:
My husband loves chocolate and peanut butter. I took the idea from my Death by Oreo Cupcakes and did something for him. Sometimes the simple ideas are the best.
Make it Your Way...

Personalize This
Kitchen Crew
Oh my! How could you not fall in love with these sweeties?! The aroma of peanut butter filled the kitchen as we were prepping them... We could hardly wait for the first bite. Delicious!


Preheat oven to 350.Take 12 NutterButter cookies and cut them in half.Line cupcake tins with cupcake papers and drop a half a cookie in the bottom of each.
Mix cake mix according to directions on the box.
Chop approx 12 cookies coarsely and mix them in the cake mix.
Fill the cupcake tins and bake aprrox 15-18 min.
Prepare Frosting
Cream togather peanut butter and butter. Add vanilla. Slowly add powdered sugar. Add cream or milk to thin the frosting as desirsed.
Frost cupcake ..leave a well in the center the place a dab of chocolate frosting and place a mini NutterButter on top.

1-5 of 236 comments

Showing OLDEST First
(Switch to Newest First)
user Debbie wright debbie110772 - May 29, 2011
Debbie wright [debbie110772] has shared this recipe with discussion groups:
I NEED a Picture to Cook!!!
"Cakes from Cake Mixes"
Southern Cooks Unite
user Doreen Fish dfish - May 29, 2011
yum!! Thank u Debbie...looks awesome!!
user Peggy Boss Davidsmom - May 29, 2011
ok so now i hafta do these!! i made your death by oreo cupcakes and had 1 lady eat 2 at 1 sitting, and wanted another... i was like ummm lol i think i better cut you off for at least an hr lol cuz thats alot of chocolate lol
user Debbie wright debbie110772 - May 30, 2011
HAHA..Peggy that's funny. She needed a oreo intervention!!!
user Kay Lott all4ukid - May 30, 2011
looks yummy!

Gift Membership