Original Coney Island Chili



Since most hot dog vendors use a canned version of this magical condiment, this recipe will help you remember why this dog became so famous! Also amazing for creating a chili-cheeseburger or making sloppy joe's!

★★★★★ 1 vote
Makes 4 to 6 dogs, depending on how much chili you like!
30 Min
45 Min


Add to Grocery List

1 lb
80 / 20 ground chuck
1/3 lb
pepperoni, finely ground [this can be easily done in a food processor]
3 Tbsp
white onion, grated on microplane
1 Tbsp
kosher salt
1 Tbsp
light brown sugar
16 ounce can(s)
tomato paste
1 Tbsp
liquid smoke flavoring
1 1/2 tsp
chili powder
1 tsp
ground cumin
1/2 tsp
celery seed
1/2 tsp
ground white pepper
1/4 tsp
cayenne pepper
3/4 c
v8 juice
1/4 c
finely ground cornmeal

How to Make Original Coney Island Chili


  • 1Brown ground chuck in a skillet. Drain approximately half the residual oil. Add ground pepperoni and grated onion and brown for another minute or two.
  • 2combine in kosher salt, brown sugar, chili powder, cumin, celery seed, cayenne and combine to meat mixture.
  • 3Reduce heat and add tomato paste, liquid smoke and V8 juice and bring to a simmer.
  • 4When chili has come to a low bubbling simmer, add cornmeal and cook low and slow for another 15 minutes.
  • 5Ladle over hotdogs or grilled burgers. This is a welcome sauce for grated sharp cheddar cheese and minced onions, but a true Coney Dog uses classic yellow mustard and a sprinkling of onions. Enjoy!

Printable Recipe Card

About Original Coney Island Chili

Show 6 Comments & Reviews

22 Zucchini Recipes That'll Make You A Cooking Rock Star

22 Zucchini Recipes That'll Make You a Cooking Rock Star

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Make the most out your summer cooking with delicious zucchini recipes. They'll make you a cooking rock star.

Easy Homemade Soup Recipes

Easy Homemade Soup Recipes

Kitchen Crew

In my part of the country, one day it's cold the next it's warm. I'm not sure Mother Nature can figure out what season it is. Even if the weather...

18 Delicious Ways To Eat More Cabbage This Year Recipe

18 Delicious Ways to Eat More Cabbage This Year

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Did you know that cabbage is the ultimate weight-loss food?! Only about 15 calories in one cup...so dress it up however you want (cough WITH THESE REALLY GOOD CABBAGE RECIPES...