Creole Mac & Cheese

Leah Stacey Recipe

By Leah Stacey CookingMaven

Cook Time:

I love mac and cheese! This is my most favorite recipe. I love the spice in this dish. It's sooo easy to make too!

Blue Ribbon Recipe

Notes from the Test Kitchen:
Way to spice up a traditional favorite! This recipe is so smooth and creamy, and I love how well the cottage cheese blends right in to give it an even lovelier texture. (So don't shy away from trying it!) We went light on the spices, but season as you see fit! This is A+ mac & cheese.


1 1/2 c
elbow macaroni
2 c
cottage cheese, lowfat
8 oz
sour cream, lite
egg, beaten
1/4 tsp
dash of pepper
3 c
grated sharp cheddar (divided)
1 1/2 Tbsp
tony chachere's creole seasoning (divided)

Directions Step-By-Step

Cook Macaroni noodles according to package directions. Drain rinse and set aside.
Combine next six ingredients. Except divide 1 cup of the cheddar cheese and set aside. Combine the other 2 cups with the mixture. Also set aside about 1/2 a TBL Spoon of the 1 1/2 TBL spoon of creole seasoning to sprinkle on top.
Add macaroni to cheese mixture and stir well. Spoon into lightly greased 9x13 casserole dish. Sprinkle with remaining Cheese and creole seasoning.
If you don't like creole seasoning you can always add paprika instead. Just adjust the amount to taste.
Bake uncovered at 350 for 35 to 45 minutes

About this Recipe

Course/Dish: Pasta, Pasta Sides
Main Ingredient: Pasta
Regional Style: Cajun/Creole
Other Tag: Quick & Easy

You May Also Like:



Leanne Macias luvs2pardy
Jul 8, 2015
Making baked paprika chicken & thought this would be a good pairing. So looks like it might be a once a month thing (not once a wk like hubby wanted) so far for a side dish. I jus can't mention enuff about how ez & delicious we think this is.

Oh & I Finally! got the Creole seasoning you suggested Leah :D Can't wait to see how much, if any, change in the taste it gives.
Leanne Macias luvs2pardy
Jun 14, 2015
Me, too Leah :D

I made it again last Sun (the 7th) bc our daughter was here visiting & it seemed like a perfect match as a side to her stuffed burgers she was making. I only made 2 changes: omitted the blk ppr (still didn't have the Cajun seasoning, which I really want to get still, for nxt time) for 2 reasons; our daughter doesn't like it, esp w/pasta & using both white & blk is jus too much ppr (even for us); added fresh lobster tail meat, coarsely chopped. Oh well, make that 3. I also remembered to change the red ppr flakes & tried chili powder.

Evry1 that nite loved it. My husband kept raving about it. And saying I don't kno what u put in this but keep making it the same way. The nxt day he also reqt'd to have it once a wk, idk bout that lol This coming frm a man who has nvr ever really liked mac n cheese! :D :-)
Leah Stacey CookingMaven
May 1, 2015
Leanne I am so glad y'all liked it so much. This has made my day!
Leanne Macias luvs2pardy
Apr 28, 2015
Despite my error w/the pepper, my husband & I agree it was the best mac n ch dish I have made yet :) (all my other attempts w/other recipes, w/or w/o rues have not been vry successful, at least not 'til revamped the nxt day).

I kno all the reviews were really good but I wasn't sure how the sour crm & cottage cheese would wrk to make this a good mac n cheez but it wrk'd vry well. I also noticed some variations ppl mentioned using proteins. Sounds like this recipe has unlimited possibilities w/an awesome base!
Leanne Macias luvs2pardy
Apr 28, 2015
I'm in the process of making this for our dinner 2nite, well its in the oven now. I was vry happy & relieved to find a recipe (finally!) for a side dish 2nite bc every recipe I was coming across I was missing 1, 2 or more ingred's. I kno, I kno that's poor planning on my part :( lol Found this 1 in my recipe box & had everything it called for, Yay for me :D 'cept the creole seasoning but I read the comments 'til I came across a suitable sub I liked the sound of. Pam B. (frm pg 4) used red, blk & white pepper. The only thing is she didn't say how much she used of ea & when I saw red I automatically thought flakes, so I did 1/2 T ea to keep w/the amt of seasoning in the recipe. I tasted it b4 I put it in the oven & it seemed a vry peppery. Luckily we like pepper & spicy stuff a lot :)

Aftr baking: yeah, it is wayyy too peppery, even for us. I threw a few more handfuls of grt'd ch on it & put it back in the oven, of course, I don't think its gonna help too much. I couldn't think of anything else to help make the dish better...any suggestions?