By JANE LOUISE lovinspoonful

Prep Time:
Cook Time:

I have named this cake appropriately because that's what people say when they ask for the recipe. I have an Amish friend named Rosie. She gave me this recipe one day and I didn't believe her at first. I thought she surely forgot an ingredient or two. But, she didn't. This is a moist cake and tasty. No icing is needed so it makes a nice lunchbox dessert.


1 box cake mix, any flavor
3 large eggs beaten
1 can pie filling, any flavor

Directions Step-By-Step

In bowl, dump dry cake mix, eggs and pie filling. Stir together until well mixed. Bake in greased 9x13, 350 degrees for 35 minutes or test with toothpick for doneness.
NOTE: Pair flavors of cake mix and pie filling. Apple filling with maybe butter pecan cake mix. Cherry pie filling with a devil's food cake mix, etc. I enjoy a pineapple cake mix with blueberry filling.
FOR AN EXTRA INCH TO THE HIPS: Chop room temp cream cheese into chunks. Poke the chunks randomly into the batter after pouring it in the baking pan. Make sure the cheese is in deep. Continue to bake. I do this with a strawberry cake mix and strawberry filling and also the blueberry filling.

About this Recipe

Course/Dish: Cakes
Collection: Back to School
Other Tag: Quick & Easy

You May Also Like:



William Kiehl Wkiehl101
Wednesday, May 20 at 5:59 AM
I tried this using a box of Swiss chocolate cake mix and a can of cherry pie filling. It was okay but for some reason I expected more. Maybe the flavor combination was a miss; I will have to try something else...
Kristi Wilson Kristi8
Apr 25, 2015
Made this for the first time 2 days ago. I mixed it by hand just until blended. It raised BEAUTIFULLY! (I credit part of that to the Betty Crocker Devil's Food mix). I made it in a glass pan, so I wound up having to add some time, about another 15 minutes or so. We sampled it plain, without frosting. We all agreed it needed a little more. We tried it with chocolate, buttercream, vanilla, and finally vanilla with added marischino cherry juice. The cherry juice added vanilla was absolutely the winner! It was a bit thin, but added just a little extra . My husband is STILL raving over how good it was and he even said it was one of the BEST cakes he has ever tasted. (WOW!)

Thanks for this super easy, practically fool proof black forest cake recipe! (my husband says to say THANK YOU as well.)
Camilla ONeal Bamcam64
Dec 6, 2014
The lemon cake sounds awesome Micki;)I think curd would be ok.Or better yet use yogart key lime or lemon.My husband loves key lime pies.I may have to try making that and I will let you know how it turns out.:))
Leigh Nycum lnycum
Nov 19, 2014
This sounds wonderful. Will try this weekend
Alana Helmick Alana_Helmick
Oct 3, 2014
I also love making one more addition to the recipe when I make it with certain combinations.... Instead of icing some of the combos, it makes the cakes even more moist and delicious (not to mention a little more unique compared to the similar cakes my family members make) - I like to wait until the cake has cooled, poke holes down through it all the way across and down the length (while it's in a pan, of course lol) and pour warm jello of a complimentary flavor across the cake. Since the jello is still warm, and there are holes poked through to the bottom of the cake, the jello sinks down through. It adds moisture without making the cake soggy, and it also adds an extra little kick of flavor. This works especially well for the following combos: Strawberry cake mix with strawberry pie filling and strawberry jello, yellow cake mix with cherry pie filling and cherry jello, and especially the buttery rich yellow or angel's food cake mix with peach pie filling and apricot jello. That last one will win you the "favorite cake of the family holiday dinner" almost every time lol :-P It's always best to serve these cakes with cool whip since icing them is so difficult and doesn't taste right anyway (and not just because it would be entirely too rich with icing). The jello clashes with every icing I've ever tried. I hope that this tip helps you guys out as much as it helped me at Easter, July 4th, Halloween, Thanksgiving, AND Christmas :-D