ARE YOU KIDDING CAKE

ARE YOU KIDDING CAKE Recipe
loading...
loading...
Recipe Rating:
 36 Ratings
Categories: Cakes, Quick & Easy
Collections: Back to School
Serves: 12-15
Prep Time:
Cook Time:

Ingredients

1 box cake mix, any flavor
3 large eggs beaten
1 can pie filling, any flavor
Pinched by smccammon, and 2,804 more.
x6
Well Seasoned
CLARKSTON, MI (pop. 332,561)
lovinspoonful
Member Since Feb 2010
JANE's Notes:

I have named this cake appropriately because that's what people say when they ask for the recipe. I have an Amish friend named Rosie. She gave me this recipe one day and I didn't believe her at first. I thought she surely forgot an ingredient or two. But, she didn't. This is a moist cake and tasty. No icing is needed so it makes a nice lunchbox dessert.

 

Directions

1
In bowl, dump dry cake mix, eggs and pie filling. Stir together until well mixed. Bake in greased 9x13, 350 degrees for 35 minutes or test with toothpick for doneness.
2
NOTE: Pair flavors of cake mix and pie filling. Apple filling with maybe butter pecan cake mix. Cherry pie filling with a devil's food cake mix, etc. I enjoy a pineapple cake mix with blueberry filling.
3
FOR AN EXTRA INCH TO THE HIPS: Chop room temp cream cheese into chunks. Poke the chunks randomly into the batter after pouring it in the baking pan. Make sure the cheese is in deep. Continue to bake. I do this with a strawberry cake mix and strawberry filling and also the blueberry filling.
Comments

1-12 of 215 comments

Showing OLDEST First
(Switch to Newest First)
jmulliki
May 26, 2010
I love Amish recipes. They're usually time savers. Thanks. I'll try this.
Mikizinaniisii
Cheryl Allen Mikizinaniisii
May 27, 2010
Sound delightful. My mom taught me a trick to making a cake moister, whether it is a boxed mix, or home made, always add an extra egg. It keeps it moist no matter what.
julescakes
Julie Hatley julescakes
May 30, 2010
Very interesting-so easy...I'm always looking for something yummy and quick...I am a cake decorator, so I bake ALOT-and when it comes to my family, I frankly don't want to put alot of effort into it, this is just the trick!
jenniferg6775
Jennifer Gonzalez jenniferg6775
Jun 2, 2010
I made this last week for our "Thursday Girls Night", everyone loved it. So just 2 days later they asked me to make 2 more cakes. They are so yummy and I've never had a more moist cake.
Utahn
Jul 24, 2010
I just made this cake and had a big piece. Wonderful! I am particularly impressed with the fact that it does not contain oil in the recipe, and it doesn't even need it. It took me less than five minutes to have it in the oven. So easy! This is my "Go to" recipe forever! I can't wait to try the other cakes that you suggested. Thanks for posting this great time-saving and tasty recipe!
lovinspoonful
Jul 24, 2010
I'm so glad you liked it Bonnie. I have a cake recipe that is MY go to cake. It's the Moist Cake Recipe of mine. Take a plain old cake mix, make as directed and add 1 Cup Buttermilk and a small box of pudding mix to the batter. I use a pudding mix flavor that matches the cake flavor...like Pumpkin Spice Pudding mix with the spice cake, or Butterscotch pudding mix with the spice cake mix....etc. The real good one is the strawberry cake mix with a cheesecake pudding mix....and a cherry cake mix with a pistachio pudding mix. Make SURE THE PUDDING MIX IS INSTANT. Add raisins, walnuts, etc. to a spice cake then and it's delicious.
KarenV
Karen Vandevander KarenV
Jul 26, 2010
Hi Jane Louise! I've been doing this for years with a chocolate cake mix and cherry pie filling. If you haven't tried it, give it a shot...sooooo delish. I also use only 1 egg instead of 3. This makes for a more dense cake. I've also made it eliminating the eggs completely and using sour cream instead. Makes dense and gooey cake.
lovinspoonful
Jul 26, 2010
I might try less eggs when I add raisins or dates. They tend to make the batter more moist and then the cake falls apart a little. Thanks.
justval1953
Val Russell justval1953
Aug 14, 2010
made this with the dark chocolate mix and cherry pie filling...OMG....goooooood!
Thanks
lovinspoonful
Aug 14, 2010
A chocolate cake with cherries is called a Black Forest Cake. How easy was THAT, huh? I'm glad you liked it Val.
Utahn
Aug 15, 2010
Jane, can this cake be made in a bundt pan? Thanks!
lovinspoonful
Aug 15, 2010
Not really because it's a little denser than most cake mixes and it wouldn't raise like a bundt pan calls for. It's almost like a brownie mix consistancy but comes out moist.

Gift Membership